Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in EnglishGoethe, Johann Wolfgang von
History
Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in English
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von
Art; Literature -- History and criticism
We shall even go farther, and confess that we have derived great
pleasure from Mannerists, when the manner has not been carried too far,
and that we are pleased with the possession of their works. The artists
who have received this name have been gifted with uncommon talent, but
became early aware that, in the state of the times as well as of the
schools into which they were cast by fate, there was no room for minute
labor, but that they must choose their part, and perfect themselves
speedily. They therefore made themselves a language, into which they
could, without farther trouble, translate with ease and dexterity
all visible subjects, and exhibit to us representations of all sorts
of scenes with greater or less success. Thus whole nations have been
entertained and hoodwinked for long periods of time, until at last one
or another artist has found the way back to nature and a higher feeling
of art.
We may perceive, by the Herculanean antiquities, how the ancients also
fell into this kind of manner; only their models were too great, too
present, fresh, and well preserved, for their second and third rate
artists to be able to lose themselves entirely in insignificance.
Let us now assume a higher and more agreeable point of view, and
consider the talent with which Raphael was so singularly gifted. Born
with the happiest natural gifts, at a time when art combined the most
conscientious labor, attention, industry, and truth, the young man was
already led by excellent masters to the threshold, and had only to
raise his foot to enter the temple. Disciplined by Perugino in the most
careful elaboration, his genius was developed by Leonardo da Vinci and
Michelangelo. Neither of these artists, in spite of their long life
and the cultivation of their powers, seems ever to have reached the
true enjoyment of artistic production. The former, if we look closely,
wearied himself with thought, and dissipated his powers in mechanical
inquiries; and we have to blame the latter for spending his fairest
years among stone quarries, getting out marble blocks and slabs, so
that, instead of carrying out his intention of carving all the heroes
of the Old and New Testament, he has left only his Moses as an example
of what he could and should have done. Raphael, however, during his
whole life, ever increased in the even facility of his work. We see
in him the development of the intellectual and active powers, which
preserve such remarkable balance that it may be affirmed that no modern
artist has possessed such purity and completeness of thought and such
clearness of expression. In him we have another instance of a talent
that pours out to us the freshest water from the purest source. He
never affects a Greek manner, but feels, thinks, works like a Greek. We
see the fairest talent developed in the most favorable hours. The same
thing occurred, under like conditions and circumstances, in the time of
Pericles.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account