Gout, with a section on ocular disease in the goutyLlewellyn, Llewellyn J. (Llewellyn Jones)
Science
Gout, with a section on ocular disease in the gouty
Llewellyn, Llewellyn J. (Llewellyn Jones)
Eye -- Diseases; Gout
_Sex._—In the matter of liability to gout the sexes stand in marked
contrast, the disorder being infinitely more common in males. Out of
eighty cases submitted to the French Academy, seventy-eight were men
and only two women; but according to other authorities, this is an
under-estimate. Thus in James Lindsay’s series of cases of gout, 84·7 per
cent. were males, 15·3 per cent. females, percentages which he notes “are
in accordance with the observations of other writers.” J. Lambert, out of
125 examples of gout, noted that 102 were men, _i.e._, 81·6 per cent.,
twenty-three women, _i.e._, 18·4 per cent.
From my own experience, the figures submitted to the French Academy
probably represent the ratio of incidence in males as opposed to females.
This certainly, if _regular_, in opposition to “irregular,” types of gout
be the criterion; for it must be admitted that regular gout does occur
in women, though exceptionally rare either prior or subsequent to the
climacteric.
As to the current opinion that the _regular_ manifestations of gout
in women are of _asthenic_ as opposed to sthenic character, this has,
I think, often proved a source of fallacy. At any rate, in many of
these cases the assumed _gouty_ inflammation resolves itself into one
of inflamed _bunion_. Again, in but too many instances, women, showing
_Heberden’s nodes_, are held to have gout or “rheumatic gout.” The latter
term, as Pye-Smith observed, “is a bad name for _osteoarthritis_,” to
which category Heberden’s nodes belong.
Judged by the one unequivocal diagnostic criterion, _i.e._, _tophi_,
gout in women is extremely rare. If to this be added the further fact,
viz., the rarity in their sex of classical attacks in the _great toe_,
we see clearly that the diagnosis of gout in women is often a matter of
_assumption_ rather than of certitude.
Moreover, having regard to the fact that the diagnosis of gout in women
is frequently based on so-called “masked and irregular manifestations,”
I must admit that, to my mind, statistics, purporting to indicate the
percentage incidence of gout in women and men, are not very convincing.
As to the why and wherefore of the relative immunity of _women_ it may be
due to the fact that their habits and mode of life are less calculated
to evoke the disorder. There is also the further possibility that the
_catamenial_ discharges to a certain extent are protective against gout,
for most authorities support Hippocrates’ aphorism, “Mulier podagra non
laborat nisi ipsi menstrua defecerint.”
_Heredity._—By the ancient physicians gout was held to be hereditary,
and even to-day most will agree that “From father to son its seeds are
transmitted, and bear fruit in exact proportion to the degree in which
circumstances prove favourable to their growth.” Cullen, indeed, went
further and held it _purely hereditary_; but, on the other hand, the
belief, that it is often _acquired_ is widely countenanced.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account