History of English Literature Volume 3 (of 3)Taine, Hippolyte
History
History of English Literature Volume 3 (of 3)
Taine, Hippolyte
English literature -- History and criticism
we forget the voice in the emotion which it expresses, we feel this
emotion reflected in ourselves, we enter into relations with a soul.
Then form seems to fade away and disappear: I think that this is the
great feature of modern poetry; seven or eight times has Burns reached
it.
He has done more; he has made his way, as we say nowadays. On the
publication of his first volume he became suddenly famous. Coming to
Edinburgh, he was feasted, caressed, admitted on a footing of equality
in the best drawing-rooms, amongst the great and the learned, loved of a
woman who was almost a lady. For one season he was sought after, and he
behaved worthily amidst these rich and noble people. He was respected,
and even loved. A subscription brought him a second edition and five
hundred pounds. He also at last had won his position, like the great
French plebeians, amongst whom Rousseau was the first. Unfortunately, he
brought thither, like them, the vices of his condition and of his
genius. A man does not rise with impunity, nor, above all, desire to
rise with impunity: we also have our vices, and suffering vanity is the
first of them. "Never did a heart pant more ardently than mine to be
distinguished," said Burns. This grievous pride marred his talent, and
threw him into follies. He labored to attain a fine epistolary style,
and brought ridicule on himself by imitating in his letters the men of
the academy and the court. He wrote to his lady-loves with choice
phrases, full of periods as pedantic as those of Dr. Johnson. Certainly
we dare hardly quote them, the emphasis is so grotesque.[89] At other
times he committed to his commonplace-book literary expressions that
occurred to him, and six months afterwards sent them to his
correspondents as extemporary effusions and natural improvisations. Even
in his verses, often enough, he fell into a grand conventional
style;[90] brought into play sighs, ardors, flames, even the big
classical and mythological machinery. Béranger, who thought or called
himself the poet of the people, did the same. A plebeian must have much
courage to venture on always remaining himself, and never slipping on
the court dress. Thus Burns, a Scottish villager, avoided, in speaking,
all Scotch village expressions: he was pleased to show himself as
well-bred as fashionable folks. It was forcibly and by surprise that his
genius drew him away from the proprieties: twice out of three times his
feeling was marred by his pretentiousness.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account