History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present timeWhewell, William
History
History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present time
Whewell, William
Science -- History
2. _Technical Forms of the Platonists._--The other sects of the Greek
philosophy, as well as the Aristotelians, invented and adopted
technical terms, and thus gave fixity to their tenets and consistency
to their traditionary systems; of these I will mention a few.
A technical expression of a contemporary school has acquired perhaps
greater celebrity than any of the terms of Aristotle. I mean the
_Ideas_ of Plato. The account which Aristotle gives of the origin of
these will serve to explain their nature.[37\1] "Plato," says he,
"who, in his youth, was in habits of communication first with
Cratylus and the Heraclitean opinions, which represent all the
objects of sense as being in a perpetual flux, so that concerning
these no science nor certain {76} knowledge can exist, entertained
the same opinions at a later period also. When, afterwards, Socrates
treated of moral subjects, and gave no attention to physics, but, in
the subjects which he did discuss, arrived at universal truths, and
before any man, turned his thoughts to definitions, Plato adopted
similar doctrines on this subject also; and construed them in this
way, that these truths and definitions must be applicable to
something else, and not to sensible things: for it was impossible,
he conceived, that there should be a general common definition of
any sensible object, since such were always in a state of change.
The things, then, which were the subjects of universal truths he
called _Ideas_; and held that objects of sense had their names
according to Ideas and after them; so that things participated in
that Idea which had the same name as was applied to them."
[Note 37\1: Arist. Metaph. i. 6. The same account is repeated, and
the subject discussed, Metaph. xii. 4.]
In agreement with this, we find the opinions suggested in the
_Parmenides_ of Plato, the dialogue which is considered by many to
contain the most decided exposition of the doctrine of Ideas. In
this dialogue, Parmenides is made to say to Socrates, then a young
man,[38\1] "O Socrates, philosophy has not yet claimed you for her
own, as, in my judgment, she will claim you, and you will not
dishonor her. As yet, like a young man as you are, you look to the
opinions of men. But tell me this: it appears to you, as you say,
that there are certain _Kinds_ or _Ideas_ (εἰδὴ) of which things
partake and receive applications according to that of which they
partake: thus those things which partake of _Likeness_ are called
_like_; those things which partake of _Greatness_ are called
_great_; those things which partake of _Beauty_ and _Justice_ are
called _beautiful_ and _just_." To this Socrates assents. And in
another part of the dialogue he shows that these Ideas are not
included in our common knowledge, from whence he infers that they
are objects of the Divine mind.
[Note 38\1: Parmenid. p. 131.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account