Women -- Suffrage -- History; Women -- Suffrage -- United States -- History; Women's rights -- History; Women's rights -- United States -- History
George Thompson: I have listened to the arguments advanced on
this side and on that side of this vexed question. I listened
with profound attention to the arguments of Mr. Burnet, expecting
that from him, as I was justified in expecting, I should hear the
strongest arguments that could be adduced on this, or any other
subject upon which he might be pleased to employ his talents, or
which he might adorn with his eloquence. What are his arguments?
Let it be premised, as I speak in the presence of American
friends, that that gentleman is one of the best controversialists
in the country, and one of the best authorities upon questions of
business, points of order, and matters of principle. What are
the strongest arguments, which one of the greatest champions on
any question which he chooses to espouse, has brought forward?
They are these:
1st. That English phraseology should be construed according
to English usage.
2d. That it was never contemplated by the anti-slavery
committee that ladies should occupy a seat in this
Convention.
3d. That the ladies of England are not here as delegates.
4th. That he has no desire to offer an affront to the ladies
now present.
Here I presume are the strongest arguments the gentleman has to
adduce, for he never fails to use to the best advantage the
resources within his reach. I look at these arguments, and I
place on the other side of the question, the fact that there are
in this assembly ladies who present themselves as delegates from
the oldest societies in America. I expected that Mr. Burnet
would, as he was bound to do, if he intended to offer a
successful opposition to their introduction into this Convention,
grapple with the constitutionality of their credentials. I
thought he would come to the question of title. I thought he
would dispute the right of a convention assembled in
Philadelphia, for the abolition of slavery, consisting of
delegates from different States in the Union, and comprised of
individuals of both sexes, to send one or all of the ladies now
in our presence. I thought he would grapple with the fact, that
those ladies came to us who have no slavery from a country in
which they have slaves, as the representatives of two millions
and a half of captives. Let gentlemen, when they come to vote on
this question, remember, that in receiving or rejecting these
ladies, they acknowledge or despise [loud cries of No, no]. I ask
gentlemen, who shout "no," if they know the application I am
about to make. I did not mean to say you would despise the
ladies, but that you would, by your vote, acknowledge or despise
the parties whose cause they espouse. It appears we are prepared
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account