Humanism and America : $b Essays on the outlook of modern civilisation
Philosophy
Humanism and America : $b Essays on the outlook of modern civilisation
Humanism; Literature -- Philosophy; Philosophy, Modern; United States -- Civilization -- 20th century
Croce is the pope of the new school, and as such ought to be immune
from the questioning of the lay intelligence. For a more accessible
exposition of the ideas stirring the young modernists, I turn to the
distinguished critic and philosopher of Spain, José Ortega y Gasset,
and in particular to his essay published under the significant title of
_The Dehumanization of Art_.[20] Unless I mistake his language, Señor
Ortega finds little satisfaction æsthetically in the extreme products
of the movement he describes. But he believes that it is not the
function of a critic to value works of art in accordance with his own
taste or distaste. And especially to-day, when more than ever before
it is a characteristic of art to divide mankind sharply into those who
comprehend and those who do not, the business of criticism should be to
enter into the intention of the artist, and not to judge his work from
some alien point of view, least of all to condemn. Well, Señor Ortega
in a sense comprehends; he states the various theories adopted by the
_jóvenes_ to justify their adventurous ways with admirable perspicuity
and precision--and with that final confusion at the back of his mind
which enables him to speak as one who belongs intellectually to the
movement, however practically his taste may lag a little behind its
utmost advance.
The central thesis of Señor Ortega’s book, which at once justifies his
title and summarises the most advanced attitude towards art, is exactly
this: “To rejoice or suffer with the human lot which a work of art
may incidentally suggest or present to us, is a very different thing
from the true artistic pleasure. More than that: this occupation with
the human element of the work is essentially incompatible with pure
æsthetic fruition.”[21]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account