Humanism and America : $b Essays on the outlook of modern civilisation
Philosophy
Humanism and America : $b Essays on the outlook of modern civilisation
Humanism; Literature -- Philosophy; Philosophy, Modern; United States -- Civilization -- 20th century
As for the creators, so called, there may be a young votary of art
here and there who is trying honestly to put these abstractions into
practice; and for him, I should suppose, the goal of dehumanisation and
derealisation will have been attained when his pictures are simplified
to a cunning design of line and colour with no suggestion of a definite
subject, or still further to a spread of pure colour with no design at
all; his music to a pure tone without melody or even variation; his
poems to a succession of beautiful words unsullied by sense. That would
seem to be the nearest practical equivalent to seeing a pure pane of
glass. One wonders why the pilgrim of vacuity should be so slow and
hesitant in his progress towards so easy a mark. Perhaps he foresees
that absolute art, so reached, will cease to be art at all. Perhaps
he has a foreboding that the prize if obtained would not be very
valuable. It is hard to imagine the pleasure or profit to be derived
from concentrating one’s attention upon a pane of transparent glass
until one sees nothing through it; most of us would prefer to retain
our impure perception of the flowers in the garden beyond. Despite the
majestic logic of youth we persist in thinking that such a picture
as Leonardo da Vinci’s Last Supper is a truer work of art than the
deftest whirl of colours ever painted; that the _Æneid_ is richer in
poetical joy than _Kubla Khan_ (not to mention the latest lyric from
the American colony in Paris); that Bach’s Mass in B Minor is still a
miracle and a rapture of sound. Yet all these--the painting and the
epic and the mass--are brimming with human emotion and with a brooding
sense of the eternal values of life. They are great for various
reasons, no doubt; but certainly among those reasons is the fact that
they are not art at all as the modernists would have us believe.
The simple truth is that the effort to create pure art is nothing
more than idolatry to a fetish of abstract reason--unless you prefer
to ticket it as empty conceit--and could never engage the practical
interest of any but a few witless cranks. There is a profound confusion
in Señor Ortega’s interpretation of what is happening among the mass of
the younger artists, as indeed there is often in their own statement of
what they are endeavouring to do. They may be seeking an absolute, but
it is not an absolute of purity in any sense of the word.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account