Irish ImpressionsChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
History
Irish Impressions
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Ireland -- Civilization; Irish question
I gave him a penny, whereon this group of merchants was suddenly
transfigured into a sort of mob, vociferating, ‘Against the law!
Against the law!’ and bundled him away. I hope it is not unamiable
to be so much entertained by that vision of a mob of magistrates, so
earnestly shooing away a solitary child like a cat. Anyhow, they knew
not what they did; and, what is worse, knew not that they knew not. And
they would not understand, if I told them, what legend might have been
made about that child, in the Christian ages of the world.
The point is here that the evil in the delusion does not consist in
bigotry, but in vanity. It is not that such a Belfast man thinks he
is right; for any honest man has a right to think he is right. It is
that he does think he is good, not to say great; and no honest man can
reach that comfortable conviction without a course of intellectual
dishonesty. What cuts this spirit off from Christian common sense is
the fact that the delusion, like most insane delusions, is merely
egotistical. It is simply the pleasure of thinking extravagantly
well of oneself, and unlimited indulgence in that pleasure is far
more weakening than any indulgence in drink or dissipation. But so
completely does it construct an unreal cosmos round the ego, that the
criticism of the world cannot be felt even for worldly purposes. I
could give many examples of this element in Belfast, as compared even
with Birmingham or Manchester. The Lord Mayor of Manchester may not
happen to know much about pictures, but he knows men who know about
them. But the Belfast authorities will exhibit a maniacally bad picture
as a masterpiece, merely because it glorifies Belfast. No man dare put
up such a picture in Manchester, within a stone’s-throw of Mr Charles
Rowley. I care comparatively little about the case of æsthetics;
but the case is even clearer in ethics. So wholly are these people
sundered from more Christian traditions that their very boasts lower
them; and they abase themselves when they mean to exalt themselves.
It never occurs to them that their strange inside standards do not
always impress outsiders. A great employer introduced me to several of
his very intelligent employees, and I can readily bear witness to the
sincerity of the great Belfast delusion even among many of the poorer
men of Belfast. But the sincere efforts of them and their master, to
convince me that a union with the Catholic majority under Home Rule was
intolerable to them, all went to one tune, which recurred with a kind
of chorus, ‘We won’t have the likes of them making laws for the likes
of us.’ It never seemed to cross their minds that this is not a high
example of any human morality; that judged by pagan _verecundia_ or
Christian humility or modern democratic brotherhood, it is simply the
remark of a snob. The man in question is quite innocent of all this;
he has no notion of modesty, or even of mock modesty. He is not only
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account