Liberty in the modern stateLaski, Harold J. (Harold Joseph)
Science
Liberty in the modern state
Laski, Harold J. (Harold Joseph)
Liberty; Political science
The second effect is also wholly bad. Whenever government interferes
to suppress some service which a considerable body of persons think
they require, when, also, the suppression is disapproved by a large
number of citizens, an industry to supply that service will come into
existence. Its ways will be devious, its charges will be high. It will
attract to its ranks many of the most undesirable elements in society.
It will form an army of lawbreakers whose habits are only too often
condoned by a large section of public opinion. That has been the case
with bootleggers in America and with night-clubs in London. And the
risks being great, the profits are high, the interests, consequently,
to be protected are correspondingly great. The history of these
adventures in England and America is one of organized immorality and
corruption. Condemnation by the law seems to have little or no effect
in dispelling its influence. Men and women attain power through its
means who normally would be shunned by most decent-minded persons. The
degree to which the police are corrupted by these influences is very
difficult to exaggerate. There is hardly a bribe too high for them to
pay. They are organizing, too, an adventure which stimulates every
sort of dubious instinct in perfectly ordinary people. Mr Babbitt
approaches his bootlegger, you will remember, in something like a
religious frame of mind. The night-club _habitué_ finds nothing quite
so exciting as the prospect of a raid; and he leaves his meretricious
surroundings with the sense that he knows the glory of danger and has
escaped the humdrum pettiness of suburbia. I think it bad for society
to make illegal conduct heroic. I think it still worse to make the
central figures in the drama of illegality powerful in the lives of
those to whom they purvey their service; men and women whose methods
of obtaining a living it does not occur to their clients to condemn.
Nor is it an answer to say that when the law does act, those clients
immediately desert the arrested offender which is proof that they
really disapprove. An enforcement which induces cowardice at the
critical moment in those who are _participes criminis_ does not seem to
me anything of which to be proud.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account