Medical Jurisprudence, Forensic medicine and Toxicology. Vol. 1Witthaus, R. A. (Rudolph August)
Science
Medical Jurisprudence, Forensic medicine and Toxicology. Vol. 1
Witthaus, R. A. (Rudolph August)
Medical jurisprudence; Poisons; Toxicology
Our judges and lawyers seem slow to recognize the fact that the duties
of experts are judicial, or at least quasi-judicial; to pass upon
certain facts which neither the court nor the jury can understand
without their aid. But, as we have seen from the citations just given,
judges and lawyers have fully recognized the unreliability of expert
testimony, produced as it now is in England and in this country at
the whim and selection of the parties and paid for, much or little,
according to the means of the parties.[181]
_Method of Preliminary Examination of Experts—On Medical Questions a
Licensed Physician Presumed Competent._—As the system exists here, the
only power that the court has over the selection of an expert, is to
determine, in advance of his testimony and of the elucidation of his
opinions, whether or not he is competent as an expert. But this power
affords little or no check or restriction, because in the effort to get
all the light that is possible upon the questions under consideration,
and to avoid unduly interfering with counsel in the conduct of the
case at bar, the practice has become universal, and is recognized in
the decisions and text writers, of permitting any medical man who has
a license to practise his profession, to testify as an expert, and to
give his opinion as such on any question cognate to his profession.
This is so without regard to the amount of study and experience he
may have had in the particular matter under consideration. The naked
fact that he is licensed to practise is enough. He then—that is,
after testifying that he is a practising physician—is clothed with
the garment of authority. The only way in which his knowledge can be
tested is by cross-examination as to his experience and skill, and
possibly by contrasting him as he appears upon the witness-stand and
his history as he gives it, with other and more or less experienced and
skilful men who follow him.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account