Mysteries of the missingSmith, Edward H. (Edward Henry)
History
Mysteries of the missing
Smith, Edward H. (Edward Henry)
Biography; Kidnapping; Missing persons
The claimant, though he had arrived in England in December, 1866,
made various claims and went to court once or twice but did not make
the definitive legal move to establish his position or to retrieve
the baronetcy and estates until more than three years later. Suit was
finally entered toward the end of 1870, and the trial came on before
the court of common pleas in London on the eleventh of May, 1871. This
was the beginning of one of the most intricate and remarkable law-trial
dramas to be found in the records of modern nations.
The Tichborne pretender had used the years of delay for the purpose
of gathering evidence and consolidating his case. He had sought out
and won over to his side the trusted servants of the house, the family
solicitor, students at Stonyhurst, officers of the carabineers and many
others. The school, the officers’ mess, the Tichborne seat, and many
other localities connected with the youth and young manhood of Roger
Tichborne had all been visited. In addition, the obese claimant had
further cultivated Lady Tichborne, who came to have more and more faith
in him. Originally she had written:
“He confuses everything as if in a dream, but it will not prevent me
from recognizing him, though his statements differ from mine.”
Before the suit was filed, and the case came to be tried, his memory
improved remarkably; he corrected the many errors in his earlier
statements, and his recollection quickly assimilated itself to that
of Lady Tichborne. After he had been in England for a time even his
handwriting grew to be unmistakably like that revealed in the letters
written by Roger Tichborne before his disappearance.
There was, accordingly, a very palpable stuff of evidence in favor
of the man from Australia. I have already said that the public
accepted the stranger. It needs to be recorded that every new shred
of similarity or circumstance that could be brought out only added to
the conviction of the people. This was unquestionably Roger Tichborne
and none other. Some elements asserted their opinion with a passion
that was not far from violence, and the public generally regarded the
hostile attitude of the Tichborne family as based on selfish motives.
Naturally the other Tichbornes did not want to be dispossessed in favor
of a man who had been confidently and perhaps jubilantly counted among
the dead for more than fifteen years. The man in the street regarded
the family position as natural, but reprehensible. How, it was asked,
could there be any doubt when the boy’s mother was so certain? Was
there anything surer than a mother’s instinct? To doubt seemed almost
monstrous. Accordingly, the butcher of Wagga Wagga became a public
idol, and the Tichborne family an object of aversion.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account