Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciencesWhewell, William
Philosophy
Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciences
Whewell, William
Science -- Philosophy
11. Our Conceptions, then, even when they become so clear as the
progress of knowledge requires, are not adequately expressed, or
necessarily expressed at all, by means of Definitions. We may ask,
then, whether there is any _other mode_ of expression in which we
may look for the evidence and exposition of that peculiar exactness
of thought which the formation of Science demands. And in answer to
this inquiry, we may refer to the discussions respecting many of the
Fundamental Ideas of the sciences contained in our _History_ of such
Ideas. It has there been seen that these Ideas involve many
elementary truths which enter into the texture of our knowledge,
introducing into it connexions and relations of the most important
kind, although these elementary truths cannot be deduced from any
verbal definition of the idea. It has been seen that these
elementary truths may often be enunciated by means of _Axioms_,
stated in addition to, or in preference to, Definitions. For
example, the Idea of Cause, which forms the basis of the science of
Mechanics, makes its appearance in our elementary mechanical
reasonings, not as a Definition, but by means of the Axioms that
'Causes are measured by their effects,' and that 'Reaction is equal
and opposite to action.' Such axioms, tacitly assumed or {41}
occasionally stated, as maxims of acknowledged validity, belong to
all the Ideas which form the foundations of the sciences, and are
constantly employed in the reasoning and speculations of those who
think clearly on such subjects. It may often be a task of some
difficulty to detect and enunciate in words the Principles which are
thus, perhaps silently and unconsciously, taken for granted by those
who have a share in the establishment of scientific truth: but
inasmuch as these Principles are an essential element in our
knowledge, it is very important to our present purpose to separate
them from the associated materials, and to trace them to their
origin. This accordingly I attempted to do, with regard to a
considerable number of the most prominent of such Ideas, in the
_History_. The reader will there find many of these Ideas resolved
into Axioms and Principles by means of which their effect upon the
elementary reasonings of the various sciences may be expressed. That
Work is intended to form, in some measure, a representation of the
Ideal Side of our physical knowledge;--a Table of those contents of
our Conceptions which are not received directly from facts;--an
exhibition of Rules to which we know that truth must conform.
SECT. IV.--_Clear and appropriate Ideas._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account