Yet in no national or racial group have cultural influences exercised
so restrictive an influence as among the entire female sex. Not only
has the larger world been closed to them, not only has popular opinion
assumed that “no woman has it in her,” but the bearing and rearing
of children has carried with it in the past the inescapable drudgery
of housework. And this is “a field,” as Dr. Hollingworth points out,
“where eminence is not possible.”
It was Prudhon who sneered in response to a similar argument that
“women could not even invent their distaff.” But we now know enough
about the laws of invention to realize how unfair such sneering
is. Professor Franz Boas and his school have long demonstrated
that cultural achievement and mental ability are not necessarily
correlated. For material culture, once it begins, tends to grow by
accumulation and diffusion. Each generation adds to the existing stock
of knowledge, and as the stock grows the harvests necessarily become
greater. Modern man need have no greater mental ability than the
men of the ice ages to explain why his improvements upon the myriad
machines and tools that are his yield so much larger a harvest than
the Paleolithic hunters’ improvements upon their few flint weapons
and industrial processes. For, as Professor Ogburn has well shown (in
“Social Change,” Part III) all invention contains two elements--a
growing cultural base and inventive genius to work with the materials
it furnishes. The number of new inventions necessarily grows with the
cultural base. Even 50 times 100 make only 5000, but 2 times 1,000,000
make 2,000,000. Countless generations have added their share to the
total material culture which is ours and which we shall hand down still
more enriched to posterity.
It must be at once obvious that there has been no such cultural
growth in housework. Housework has long remained an individualized,
non-cumulative industry, where daughter learns from mother the old
ways of doing things. The small improvements and ingenuities which
most housewives devise seldom find their way into the whole stream of
culture. Thus it is that the recent great inventions which are slowly
revolutionizing this last stronghold of petty individualism have come
from the man-made world. Workers in electricity could more easily
devise the vacuum cleaner than the solitary housewife; the electric
washer, parquet floors, the tin can, quantity production of stockings,
wool, clothing, bread, butter, and all the other instruments that have
really made possible women’s emancipation have naturally come not from
women’s minds (any more than from men’s) but from the growth of culture
and the minds that utilize that growth for further expansion.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account