Our Nuclear Future: Facts, Dangers and OpportunitiesTeller, Edward
Science
Our Nuclear Future: Facts, Dangers and Opportunities
Teller, Edward
Nuclear energy -- Popular works; Nuclear weapons; Radioactivity -- Physiological effect
Thus the strontium is discriminated against relative to calcium in going
from the soil to man by a factor of about 14. This is a factor of
protection.
It is good to double-check this conclusion and to find out how the
calcium to strontium ratio changes step by step in going from the soil
to man. One finds a factor of 1.4 in going from the soil to the plant, a
factor of 7 in going from the plant to the milk, and a factor of about 2
in going from the milk to man. Actually, if we put all these factors
together we should expect that on the way from the soil to man the
calcium to strontium ratio increases by a factor 20. This is in
reasonable but not in excellent agreement with the ratio 14 given above.
Once the factor of protection is established we can get a value of the
expected strontium uptake from the way in which the radioactive material
is diluted by calcium rather than by normal strontium. This is a less
straightforward but, for the time being, a more practical method than
the direct Sr⁹⁰—normal strontium comparison. It is particularly
important when one compares soils of rather different calcium content.
Plants and animals require calcium. When they do not get it, they
develop a calcium-hunger. Since strontium is chemically similar to
calcium, a lack of calcium in the soil is readily substituted by
available strontium. One would expect that plants grown on calcium-poor
soil and animals raised on such land would exhibit abnormally high
natural strontium content and also a proportionately high Sr⁹⁰ content.
The high Sr⁹⁰ content has in fact been verified. Some sheep in Wales,
for example, appear to have about ten times the average amount of Sr⁹⁰
in their bodies.
Fortunately most people derive their food from many areas widely
separated from each other. Soil that is deficient in calcium is not
likely to supply more than a small part of an individual’s sustenance.
However, the possibility of a large fluctuation cannot be ignored. In
this event corrective measures would be needed. One simple measure would
be to fertilize deficient soil with additional calcium.
That soil can be successfully treated in this way is illustrated by the
present situation in Wales. The sheep with the abnormally high Sr⁹⁰
content all come from the steep, poor pastures which are not limed. The
sheep from the lower pastures, which are limed (not because of the
fallout but for economic reasons), show an activity of only one third
the value mentioned above.
The point we have tried to make in this chapter is that the present
human levels of Sr⁹⁰ can be satisfactorily accounted for by simple
arguments based on the chemical similarity of elements and the identity
of isotopes. These arguments give us confidence that we correctly
understand how Sr⁹⁰ and how much Sr⁹⁰ is getting from the soil to the
human body.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account