Overtones, a book of temperaments : $b Richard Strauss, Parsifal, Verdi, Balzac, Flaubert, Nietzsche, and TurgénieffHuneker, James
Philosophy
Overtones, a book of temperaments : $b Richard Strauss, Parsifal, Verdi, Balzac, Flaubert, Nietzsche, and Turgénieff
Huneker, James
Music
The correspondence of King Ludwig and Wagner, of Ludwig and Josef
Kainz, the actor, throws much light on the enigmatic character
of Parsifal. Wagner needed money and encouragement, badly. So it
is not difficult to conceive of him playing up to every romantic
extravagance of the young king—“le seul vrai roi de ce siècle,” as
Paul Verlaine poetically called the monarch, whose madness admirably
matched his own. Read in this sense, the psychology of Kundry’s kiss
and its repelling effect and its arousing of pity for Amfortas in
Parsifal is no longer a mystery. Wagner never erred in his morbid
musical psychology, and he thus symbolized Amfortas—Wagner—as being
rescued from suffering by Parsifal—Ludwig. Wagner had been ever an
ungrateful man, but for the King he entertained the most exalted
sentiment of gratitude. There is a psychiatric literature on this
esoteric subject in German and French beginning with Oskar Panizza,
ending with the remarkable study of Hanns Fuchs, entitled Richard
Wagner.
Parsifal will long remain a rare and stimulating spectacle to those
for whom religious feeling must be dramatized to be endurable.
The stern simplicities of doctrinal truths have no attraction for
such. Wagner, luxuriously Byzantine in his faiths, erected a lordly
pleasure drama in which the mystically inclined, the admirer of
theatrical pomps, and the esoteric worshipper could all find solace,
amusement, and consolation. Yet Parsifal’s pale virtue can never
stir us to higher issues, as do the heroic sacrifices of Tannhäuser
or Senta. Parsifal is the predestinated one, predestined to save the
life of the King. Lacking freedom of will, he is not a human being
that provokes our sympathy—but why demand logic, even dramatic logic,
of Wagner? He was first a musician, then a poet and a philosopher;
and in the last of these three was least. Parsifal is his final
offering to the world. It is the work of a man who had outlived
his genius. Nietzsche quotes with approval the exclamation of a
musician: “I hate Wagner, but I no longer stand any other music.” We
are all Wagnerians whether we rebel at Parsifal or not.
III
NIETZSCHE THE RHAPSODIST
Tell me, where is justice to be found which is love with seeing
eyes?—_Also sprach Zarathustra._
I
A sane and complete estimate of the life and philosophical writings
of Friedrich Nietzsche has yet to be made in English. Mentally dead
since 1889, his death, in a private retreat at Weimar in 1900,
created little stir; yet we predict that this great, if rhapsodical
thinker, will occupy a place in the pantheon of philosophers. Like
Emerson, he formulated no system; he is a stimulus to thought, an
antiseptic critic of all philosophies, religions, theologies, and
moral systems, an intellectual rebel, a very Lucifer among ancient
and modern thinkers.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account