Shakespeare, William, 1564-1616 -- Stage history; Theater -- England
Of course, there are critics who will hold that Marlowe's Christians, in
some respects, are more life-like than Shakespeare's. Perhaps if "The
Merchant of Venice" had been written while Marlowe was alive, he would
have challenged Shakespeare to uphold that in matters of conduct where
money interests were involved there was any marked distinction between the
morals of the believer and the unbeliever. Marlowe might have contended
that out of one hundred Christians ninety-nine would act as his Governor
of Malta had done, though he was a Knight of St. John. It might not be
impossible for a Christian to persuade himself that money taken forcibly
from the infidel Jew, as a tribute, could justly be withheld from the
infidel Turk to whom it was due, and that it was folly to hesitate in
cutting the cord that would let the infidel Jew into the burning cauldron,
instead of the infidel Turk for whom it was designed, especially when one
hundred thousand pounds of the citizens' money would in that way be saved.
As a mere worldly truism the words that Barabas utters, when his daughter
changes her faith, have a deeper significance than the "noble platitudes"
of Lorenzo and Jessica:
"She that varies from me in belief,
Gives great presumption that she loves me not;
Or loving, does mislike of something done."
Shakespeare, probably, would have answered Marlowe's objection with the
assurance that there still remained the odd Christian out of every hundred
to be reckoned with, and that he himself was more interested in showing
the world what men ought to be like than what they actually were. But if
Shakespeare preferred to live outside the walls of reality, he did so only
in imagination, for he must have had a very practical knowledge of men's
dealings with each other. No doubt our great dramatist was not eager to
break with conventions or to imitate Marlowe by saying unpalatable truths
about the Christians at a time when he himself was still seeking the
favour of Elizabeth's Court.
THE AUTHORS OF "KING HENRY THE EIGHTH."[8]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account