Traumatic neuroses; War neuroses; World War, 1914-1918 -- Health aspects; World War, 1914-1918 -- Veterans -- Mental health
It has been said of the neurasthenic with aptness and truth that he
behaves like a child. But if a child, normal in its behaviour up to
a certain day, suddenly manifests fear of being left alone for a
moment in a room with closed doors, or in a street, do we rush for our
“Liddell and Scott” and forthwith proceed to babble of claustrophobia
or agoraphobia?[63] Do we follow this up by solemnly invoking
complicated physico-chemical theories concerning the state of his blood
or other bodily fluids? Finally, do we brand him as “insane” or at
least “neuropathic?” What we do in this case, if we have any sense, is
carefully to investigate the causes of the emotional outbreak. We try
sympathetically to understand and re-educate the child to meet such
situations without fear. In other words, we use a method precisely
similar to that which proves to be of such great use in treating the
psychoneuroses.
The analogy—if it be an analogy and not perhaps an identity—between
the two cases goes still farther. The child who manifests extreme fear
at “inadequate” causes, such as we have described, not infrequently
agonises his mother—perhaps soon after his outburst of fright—by an
exhibition of foolhardiness which, if we did not know of the previous
sign of weakness, would cause one to look upon him as fearless. In
short, the child’s fear is restricted to one or two special situations.
So it is with many neurasthenics. Some, for example, may be driven
through traffic in a fast motor car without experiencing the slightest
fear, though they cannot bring themselves to enter an ordinary slow
suburban train; others may surprise us not only by their exhibition
of anger at what we should consider an absurdly slight provocation,
but by their tolerance and self-control in other (to us) much more
annoying situations. Their exaggerated emotional reactions are excited
not by general but by specific stimuli; and a little tact, insight
and patience on the part of the physician often reveals in their
past experience, psychological factors which explain the tremendous
personal importance and overweighting of these stimuli. If for
neuropathic we write: “unduly hampered by instinct and emotion”—and
this is all we have the right to do[64]—we represent the matter more
truthfully.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account