Social Value: A Study in Economic Theory, Critical and ConstructiveAnderson, Benjamin M. (Benjamin McAlester)
General
Social Value: A Study in Economic Theory, Critical and Constructive
Anderson, Benjamin M. (Benjamin McAlester)
Value
The error consists in looking for the explanation of
social phenomena in the most general laws. This is
natural within certain limits, but has been pushed to
extreme, but logical consequences, by the American,
Carey (_Social Science_). He looks, in effect, to one
of the oldest sciences, and one, consequently, relating
to the most highly general phenomena, those of
astronomy, for the universal laws of society. Geometry,
he holds, gives us principles equally valid for the
chemist, the sociologist, and for him who measures the
earth. A system assuming to explain complex phenomena
solely by the laws of phenomena more simple, may be
compared to the effort to give an account of a book,
not by reading it line by line, but by examining the
cover and the title-page.
As DeGreef elsewhere puts it, there is a hierarchy in science, proceeding
from the more general to the less general, depending on the nature of the
phenomena studied. This hierarchy has been variously stated. Comte puts it
thus: mathematics, astronomy, physics, chemistry, physiology, social
physics (sociology). Baldwin,[101] writing much later, of course, puts it
thus:--
So here, as elsewhere, there is a gradation, a
hierarchy, in science: chemistry necessary to life, but
not itself of life; forces in the environment necessary
to evolution, but not themselves vital; life-processes
necessary to consciousness, but not themselves mental;
consciousness necessary to society, but not all
consciousness social; social consciousness necessary to
social organization, but not all social consciousness
actually in a social organization.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account