Social Work; Essays on the Meeting Ground of Doctor and Social WorkerCabot, Richard C. (Richard Clarke)
Science
Social Work; Essays on the Meeting Ground of Doctor and Social Worker
Cabot, Richard C. (Richard Clarke)
Charities, Medical; Friendly visiting; Medical social work -- United States; Social service
The idea that social work necessarily concerns the poor is wholly wrong.
It concerns the sick; it concerns the tuberculous; some of the sick and
some of the tuberculous are poor. Others are not. The State provides
dispensaries for tuberculosis, and the people pay for them out of the
taxes. Hence all the people feel that they have the right to go there
and that they are not in any sense accepting charity in going there. But
social work is done in all these dispensaries. Thus the connection
between medical and social studies is tending to upset the old idea that
social work is necessarily concerned with poverty, and that economic
studies are the main part of it.
In America our leading ideas about social work (formerly called
charity), came originally from England and from the studies of English
economists. Hence to a considerable extent economic considerations have
governed the history and evolution of social work even up to the present
day. Economists and people interested especially in political economy
have studied, practised, and spoken and written upon these subjects, and
all who are governed by the traditions inherited from England are still
obsessed by the idea that money and money troubles are the gist of
social work.
Nobody should turn up his nose at economics. Anybody who is careless in
money matters is sure to come to grief. But in my medical-social work,
which has included a large number of cases where poverty existed, I have
almost never found the economic trouble to be the essential one.
Economics is everywhere present, everywhere subordinate. That is an
adaptation of a saying of the German philosopher Lotze: "Mechanism
everywhere present, everywhere subordinate." The idea applies also to
economics which has many qualities in common with mechanics. I shall
therefore lay especial stress in this book, not upon economic but mental
deficiencies, which in most cases seem to me more fundamental than
economic need or physical weakness.
A considerable portion of all social diagnoses should contain the word
_ignorance_. I wish to distinguish ignorance from moral fault. It is
true that somebody's sin, somebody's evil-doing is the fundamental thing
in the social diagnosis of many cases. I have never yet studied
carefully a case involving social work without finding some moral
weakness as an important element in the trouble. Moral elements always
enter into the study of a case of social work, but they are often not
the main element, often subordinate.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account