Some eminent Victorians: Personal recollections in the world of art and lettersCarr, J. Comyns (Joseph Comyns)
General
Some eminent Victorians: Personal recollections in the world of art and letters
Carr, J. Comyns (Joseph Comyns)
Art, Victorian; English literature -- 19th century; Great Britain -- Intellectual life -- 19th century
It is not needful now to revive the memories of that fierce hostility of
criticism which greeted his earlier efforts. Rossetti’s determined
reticence in regard to the exhibition of his work left Burne-Jones in
those earlier days to bear the whole brunt of the attack, for the art of
Millais and Holman Hunt made a somewhat different appeal and claimed a
separate victory. Nor was it wonderful that what lay in the mind of both
to do should at first have seemed tinged by something of determined
archaic affectation. The temper of their work was strange to the world
to whom it was offered at first in a form so tentative, and also
confessedly so incomplete.
The history of English Painting, even in its greatest achievement, has
left no tradition to which they could appeal, and, indeed, if we take a
wider range of view, it may be said with equal truth that, since the
downfall of the great school of Florence, Art throughout Europe had
taken a direction which made the efforts of these younger men seem like
a wilful neglect of the accepted models of style.
Such English masters of an earlier time as had attempted to enter into
this higher realm of imaginative painting--Barry, Fuseli, and Haydon, to
name only the leaders--had wrecked their lives in the vain endeavour
suddenly to renew the splendours of the great masters of the sixteenth
century.
With the advent of the pre-Raphaelite movement, marked by a determined
research of greater reality in the rendering of actual fact, the failure
of these earlier experiments became only the more manifest; and it was
left for that little group in which Rossetti and Burne-Jones stand
pre-eminent to realise the truth that, if imagination could ever again
resume its place in pictorial art, the result must be achieved, not by
an endeavour to repeat the triumphs of the past at the epoch of its
culminating glory, but by retracing the stream to its source and
beginning again, where Florence had begun in the earlier period of her
history.
It was, I think, the first exhibition of the Grosvenor Gallery that gave
Burne-Jones’s critics reason to pause in their pitiless onslaught of
ridicule and rebuke. But even then the fight was not ended, and among
the many members of the Academy itself the hostility continued almost
without check.
I remember going round that exhibition with Mr. Gladstone, and recalling
a phrase of his which he used in reference to this very feeling that was
even then sufficiently openly expressed.
Standing before one of Burne-Jones’s pictures which he was warmly
admiring, he turned to me and said, “Dislike of such a painter I can
understand, but such intolerance of dislike as I find on every hand I do
not comprehend.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account