Statement of the Provision for the Poor, and of the Condition of the Labouring Classes in a Considerable Portion of America and Europe: Being the preface to the foreign communications contained in the appendix to the Poor-Law ReportSenior, Nassau William
History
Statement of the Provision for the Poor, and of the Condition of the Labouring Classes in a Considerable Portion of America and Europe: Being the preface to the foreign communications contained in the appendix to the Poor-Law Report
Senior, Nassau William
Poor -- Europe; Poor -- United States; Working class
4. On the mutual dependence and affection of parent, children,
and other relatives?--No doubt it materially disturbs the
natural dependence and affection of parent and child. The
latter feels his parent comparatively needless to him; he
obtains support elsewhere; and the former feels the obligation
to support the latter greatly diminished. In short, being
comparatively independent of each other, the affections must
inevitably become blunted.
5. What, on the whole, is the condition of the able-bodied
and self-supporting labourer of the lowest class, as compared
with the condition of the person subsisting on alms or public
charity; is the condition of the latter, as to food and freedom
from labour, more or less eligible?--Were I a Danish labourer,
I would endeavour to live partly on my own labour, and partly
on the parish, and I feel persuaded that a labourer so living
in Denmark will be better off than one who gets no help from
the parish; that is, the former, from a knowledge that he may
fall back on the parish, will spend all he earns at the time on
coffee, spirits, tobacco, snuff, &c., whereas the latter, who
certainly can live on his industry (except under extraordinary
and occasional emergencies, sickness, &c.) is debarred from
such gratifications. Under such circumstances, the _poorer_
labourer is better off than the _poor_ one.
And his views are supported by the following observations of Count
Holstein:
1st. The dread of poverty is diminished, and he who is
half-poor works less instead of more, so that he speedily
becomes a complete pauper. Those who are young and capable
of labour are less economical, always having the poor rate
in view, as a resource against want; likewise marriages are
contracted with much less forethought, or consideration as to
consequences.
2d. The morality of the poor man suffers, for he looks upon
his provision as a right, for which he, therefore, need not
be thankful; and, 3d, the morality of the rich man suffers,
for the natural moral relation between him and the poor man
has become completely severed; there is no place left for
the exercise of his benevolence; being obliged to give, he
does it with reluctance, and thus is the highest principle of
charitable action, Christian love, exposed to great danger of
destruction.
4th. As the clergyman of the parish is the president of the
poor committee, he becomes involved in transactions peculiarly
unsuited to his sacred calling, sometimes even compelled
to resort to the extremity of distraint to compel his own
parishioners to pay the allotted proportions; and thus does the
moral influence of him, who should be a picture of the God of
love, become every day less and less powerful. (p. 276.)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account