Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and CivilizationMumford, Lewis
History
Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and Civilization
Mumford, Lewis
Architecture -- United States
The main merit of all these efforts to perpetuate the World’s Fair is
that they sought to achieve some of the dignity and decisiveness of
the formal plan. Their weakness was that they neglected new elements,
like the billboard, the skysign, the subway, the tall building,
which undermined the effects of the plan even when it was achieved.
In their efforts to escape from the welter of misguided commercial
enterprise, the advocates of the city beautiful placed too great
reliance upon spots of outward order and decency; they took refuge in
the paper symmetry of axial avenues and round-points, as one finds
them in Haussmann’s Paris, and neglected the deeper and more genuine
beauties of, let us say, the High Street in Oxford or Chipping Camden,
or of many another European town that had achieved completion in its
essentials before the nineteenth century.
In short, the advocates of the city beautiful sought a remedy on paper
which could be purchased only by a thorough reorganization of the
community’s life. If all this applies to the better side of the World’s
Fair, it touches even more emphatically the worse.
The twenty years between 1890 and 1910 saw the complete rehabilitation
of the Roman mode, as the very cloak and costume of imperial
enterprise. The main effort of architecture was to give an effect of
dignity and permanence to the façades of the principal thoroughfares:
the public buildings must dominate the compositions, numerous
boulevards and avenues must concentrate the traffic at certain points
and guide the stranger to the markets and amusements: where possible,
as in the Chicago plan, by Messrs. Burnham and Bennett, avenues must be
cut through the gridiron pattern of blocks in order to achieve these
effects. If this imperial street system is somewhat arbitrary, and if
the necessary work of grading, filling, demolishing, and purchasing
existing property rights is extremely costly, the end, nevertheless,
justifies the means--the architecture impresses and awes a populace
that shares vicariously in it glories. Should the effect prove a little
too austere and formidable, the monuments will be offset with circuses
and hippodromes.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account