Studies in Classic American LiteratureLawrence, D. H. (David Herbert)
History
Studies in Classic American Literature
Lawrence, D. H. (David Herbert)
American literature -- History and criticism
He knows there is no new country, no new life on the globe to-day. It is
the same old thing, in different degrees, everywhere. _Plus ça change,
plus c'est la même chose._
Hester thinks, with Dimmesdale for her husband, and Pearl for her child,
in Australia, maybe, she'd have been perfect.
But she wouldn't. Dimmesdale had already fallen from his integrity as a
minister of the Gospel of the Spirit. He had lost his manliness. He
didn't see the point of just leaving himself between the hands of a
woman, and going away to a "new country," to be her thing entirely.
She'd only have despised him more, as every woman despises a man who has
"fallen" to her: despises him with her tenderest lust.
He stood for nothing any more. So let him stay where he was and dree out
his weird.
She had dished him and his spirituality, so he hated her. As Angel Clare
was dished, and hated Tess. As Jude in the end hated Sue: or should have
done. The women make fools of them, the spiritual men. And when, as men,
they've gone flop in their spirituality, they can't pick themselves up
whole any more. So they just crawl, and die detesting the female, or the
females, who made them fall.
The saintly minister gets a bit of his own back, at the last minute, by
making public confession from the very scaffold where she was exposed.
Then he dodges into death. But he's had a bit of his own back, on
everybody.
"'Shall we not meet again?' whispered she, bending her face down close
to him. 'Shall we not spend our immortal life together? Surely, surely
we have ransomed one another with all this woe! Thou lookest far into
eternity with those bright dying eyes. Tell me what thou seest!'"
"'Hush, Hester--hush,' said he, with tremulous solemnity. 'The law we
broke!--the sin here so awfully revealed! Let these alone be in thy
thoughts. I fear! I fear!'"
So he dies, throwing the "sin" in her teeth, and escaping into death.
The law we broke, indeed. You bet!
Whose law?
But it is truly a law, that man must either stick to the belief he has
grounded himself on, and obey the laws of that belief. Or he must admit
the belief itself to be inadequate, and prepare himself for a new thing.
There was no change in belief, either in Hester or in Dimmesdale or in
Hawthorne or in America. The same old treacherous belief, which was
really cunning disbelief, in the Spirit, in Purity, in Selfless Love,
and in Pure Consciousness. They would go on following this belief, for
the sake of the sensationalism of it. But they would make a fool of it
all the time. Like Woodrow Wilson, and the rest of modern Believers. The
rest of modern Saviours.
If you meet a Saviour, to-day, be sure he is trying to make an innermost
fool of you. Especially if the saviour be an UNDERSTANDING WOMAN,
offering her love.
Hester lives on, pious as pie, being a public nurse. She becomes at last
an acknowledged saint, Abel of the Scarlet Letter.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account