Such questions easily appear foolish because, as in the case just
quoted, they are directed by quaint childish fancies. The child’s
anthropomorphic way of looking out on the world leads him to assimilate
animal to human ways.
One feature in this fact-gleaning kind of question is the great store
which the child sets by the name of a thing. M. Compayré has pointed out
that the form of question: ‘What is this?’ often means, “What is it
called?” The child’s unformulated theory seems to be that everything has
its own individual name. The little boy just spoken of explained to his
mother that he thought all the frogs, the mice, the birds, and the
butterflies had names given to them by their mothers as he himself had.
Perhaps this was only a way of expressing the childish idea that
everything has its name, primordial and unchangeable.
A second direction of this early questioning is towards the reason and
the cause of things. The typical form is here ‘why?’ This form of
inquiry occurred in the case of Preyer’s boy at the age of two years
forty-three weeks. But it becomes the all-predominant form of question
somewhat later. Who that has tried to instruct the small child of three
or four does not know the long shrill whinelike sound of this question?
This form of question develops naturally out of the earlier, for to give
the ‘what?’ of a thing, that is its connexions, is to give its ‘why?’
that is its mode of production, its use and purpose.
Nothing perhaps in child utterance is better worth interpreting, hardly
anything more difficult to interpret, than this simple-looking little
‘why?’
We ourselves perhaps do not use the word ‘why’ and its correlative
‘because’ with one clear meaning; and the child’s first use of the words
is largely imitative. What may be pretty safely asserted is that even in
the most parrot-like and wearisome iteration of ‘why?’ and its
equivalents ‘what for?’ etc., the child shows a dim recognition of the
truth that a thing is understandable, that it has its reasons if only
they can be found.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account