Though these results were definitely proved by numerous researches, yet they have been repeatedly challenged, notably by J. Knoch (1862) in Petrograd, who, on the basis of experiments, sought to confirm a direct development without an intermediate host and ciliated stage, at all events as regards _Dibothriocephalus latus_. However, the repeated communications of this author met with but little favour from competent persons, partly because the experiments were conducted very carelessly, and partly because their repetition on dog and man (R. Leuckart) had no results (1863). It was only in 1883 that Braun was able to prove that the developmental cycle of _Dibothriocephalus latus_ is similar to that of other Cestodes. The results obtained in other places by Parona, Grassi, Ijima and Zschokke render any discussion of Küchenmeister’s conclusions unnecessary.[7] Long after Knoch, a French author, P. Mégnin, also pleaded for the direct development of some cestodes, and especially some tæniæ. He (1879) also sought to prove a genetic connection between the hookless and armed tapeworms of mammals, but the arguments he adduced, so far as they rest on observations, can be easily refuted or attributed to misinterpretation. Only one of these arguments is correct, namely, that the number of the species of tæniæ with which we are acquainted is far larger than that of the corresponding cystic forms; but this disparity alone cannot be taken as a proof of direct development. It can only be said that our knowledge in this respect is deficient. As a matter of fact, we have during recent years become acquainted with a large number of cystic forms, hitherto unknown, belonging to tæniæ which have long been familiar. It must also be borne in mind that no man in his lifetime can complete an examination for bladder-worms of the large number of insects, for instance, which may destroy an entire generation of an insectivorous species of bird within a small district. [7] Refer to the collected literature under _Dibothriocephalus latus_, and the reply to Küchenmeister by Braun (“Ueber den Zwischenwirt des breit. Bandw.” Würzb.: Stuber, 1886). Naturally it does not follow that direct development in the cestodes is altogether lacking. The researches of Grassi (1889) have furnished an example in _Hymenolepis_ (_Tænia_) _murina_, which shows that development may sometimes take place without an intermediate host, notwithstanding the retention of the cystic stage. It was found that the oncospheres of this species, introduced into rats of a certain age, after a time grow into tapeworms without leaving the intestine, but not directly, for they bore into the intestinal wall, where they pass the cystic stage, the cysts afterwards falling into the intestinal lumen, where they develop into tapeworms. The recent experiments of Nicoll (1911) show that the larval stages of _Hymenolepis murina_ also occur in the rat-flea, _Ceratophyllus fasciatus_.