The Camel and the Needle's EyePonsonby, Arthur Ponsonby, Baron
Philosophy
The Camel and the Needle's Eye
Ponsonby, Arthur Ponsonby, Baron
Wealth; Wealth -- Moral and ethical aspects
On all sides it is admitted that there is a problem of Poverty, but
it has never yet been suggested that just in the same way there is a
problem of Riches. Not the problem of how to become rich and how to
invest money and make more money, that is the very obsession which
ought to be dispelled, but the important question of how the rich
spend their money, how they live, to what objects they devote their
riches, and whether the vast accumulations are being disposed of to
the greatest advantage. The connection between riches and poverty is
capable of proof, that is to say, the maladministration of wealth by
individuals can be shown to be closely linked to the disorganisation
of labour which creates such evils as sweating and unemployment. But
before further advance can be made towards any possible solution there
must be a dissection and analysis of the lives of the rich as well as
of the poor, so that some knowledge may be acquired of both sides of
the medal which will demonstrate their interdependence.
We are allowed to extract every conceivable detail of the most intimate
nature from the poor householder, but any sort of inquiry as to how the
rich live is regarded as an impertinence. Even the suggestion that they
should make a return of all their income, as a man of moderate means
must do for income tax purposes, is scouted as inquisitorial.
We inquire into the lives of the poor in order to ascertain the actual
facts, so that with a full knowledge of the evil we may set to work
scientifically to improve their condition. But this is really only half
the problem. No investigation can be complete unless an equally careful
and exhaustive inquiry is made into the way the rich live. It cannot
be regarded as an inquisitive prying into personal and private habits,
for when the expenditure is on such a scale as to have extensive
economic consequences it ceases to be of a private nature and ought to
be investigated on public grounds. Not only might the inquiry be made
with a view to the improvement of their own way of living--though they
would refuse to admit there was any room for improvement--but by this
means more light would also be thrown on the problem of poverty.
It is the question of distribution that is admittedly the insoluble
difficulty, and yet we set to work to examine the barren patches and
leave out of account the land that is soured by over-fertilisation. To
accomplish a successful work of irrigation attention must not only be
turned to the dry and arid land, but to the marshy, low-lying parts
that have got more of the water than they need and require draining,
otherwise an even flow over the whole can never be engineered and the
full capacity of the soil cannot be given a fair chance.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account