The constitution violated : $b An essayButler, Josephine Elizabeth Grey
History
The constitution violated : $b An essay
Butler, Josephine Elizabeth Grey
Constitutional law -- Great Britain; Prostitutes -- Legal status, laws, etc. -- Great Britain
with the great and difficult science of governing. This deficiency is
deeply dangerous in persons who have the hardihood to assume the
responsibility of prompting the legislative measures of those who are
bound to hold themselves accountable to the people alone. While
observing the overwhelming influence which these professionals have
lately been allowed in the making of laws for the whole nation, I have
sometimes been appalled at the evidence which comes before us of their
profound ignorance of English history, its noble struggles, the
structure and resources of our political system, and the great
constitutional principles which we hold dear. They seem to have as
little appreciation of these matters as they have of the feelings and
souls of human beings. Their ignorance both of our political
constitution, and of the principles which animate human nature, are
proved by their audacious attempts at wholesale compulsion.[89] They
scarcely would have succeeded had they brought their present tactics to
bear upon a nation barely emerging from childhood, and accustomed to
obey the rule of a despotic monarch. How dangerous is their attempt when
made upon a people to whom constitutional freedom is dear, will be
proved by the future ruin of the influence of that whole class which has
attempted it. The limitations of their education produce a narrowness of
intellect, which blinds them to the limits of their own legitimate
influence. Hence the fatal mistake into which they have fallen.
Compulsion is dear to them as life; the passion for compulsion grows by
the indulgence granted to them by our foolish legislators. Who can tell
to what they will compel us next? For their ignorance of history and of
human nature lead them to run riot in our political constitution, which
they do not understand; they tell us such and such questions are purely
medical questions, while they are secretly, through carelessness or
ignorance, or consciously, robbing us like burglars in the night of our
cherished inherited safeguards, dearer to us than wealth or health; and
by the arbitrary measures which they persuade a credulous or ignorant
Legislature to adopt, by suspending the liberties of the citizen on all
hands, and finally by abandoning the vital principle of jury trial in
order that a project of theirs may work, they have at last taken that
fatal step towards “establishing aristocracy, the most oppressive of
absolute governments.” And let the people of England never forget that
the government of an aristocracy does not consist in that of wealth or
hereditary privileges so much as in that arbitrary power of a particular
class, whose enactments are permitted to override the safeguards of our
Constitution.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account