The constitution violated : $b An essayButler, Josephine Elizabeth Grey
History
The constitution violated : $b An essay
Butler, Josephine Elizabeth Grey
Constitutional law -- Great Britain; Prostitutes -- Legal status, laws, etc. -- Great Britain
But this “self-government which is life” has been despised by those
holding a commission from the nation. Was this law against which we
contend made by the nation? Assuredly not. Nay, nor was it even made by
Parliament, but by a mere fraction of Parliament casting off for a time
the faith and responsibility of men commissioned by the nation. The
people were not yet so degraded as to consent to such a law. Even where
their education is but poor, the people nevertheless still know right
from wrong; they are yet able to distinguish between truth and
falsehood, between freedom and slavery. It may be said of our industrial
classes generally as Lord Chatham said of our forefathers who framed the
Great Charter:—“Their virtues were rude and uncultivated, but they were
great and sincere; their understandings were as little polished as their
manners, but they had hearts to distinguish right from wrong; they had
heads to distinguish truth from falsehood; they understood the rights of
humanity, and they had spirit to maintain them.”
All the evils incident to our system of government arise when that
government ceases at any period to be honestly representative of those
masses of the people whose spirit we have described; and it is evident
that when our rulers are swayed too much by any particular class in the
community, they become no longer truly representative.
The narrower the class of persons exercising this undue influence, the
greater is the danger; and that danger is heightened still further when
this influence proceeds exclusively from men of one profession. The
profession to which I now allude is the medical profession. I wish to
guard myself against the suspicion of a general and unreasoning
prejudice against this profession, which Guizot has styled “the
mournfullest and the noblest.” We have all of us too much reason to be
grateful to men of that profession, many of whom we know by experience
to be among the truest friends of humanity. But physicians who hang
about courts, who have the ear of royalty, and of aristocratic public
officers, and who exercise an influence over superstitious households of
the great, somewhat resembling that formerly exercised by the priest in
Italy and Spain, when allowed to influence our legislation in the direct
manner which they have done of late, must be content to endure the
searching judgment of the people at large, and ultimately to fall under
the people’s indignation, if they be found to be interfering with our
laws, in defiance or in ignorance of the principles of our Constitution.
Such medical men have not unfrequently risen to posts of honour, high
among the aristocracy of the land, by an energy and talent which we
cannot fail to admire; but it cannot be denied that they frequently
attain to excellence in the single line of professional study to which
they have been necessarily devoted, at the expense of other portions of
education essentially needful for those who would venture on meddling
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account