The Cornhill Magazine (Vol. I, No. 3, March 1860)Various
History
The Cornhill Magazine (Vol. I, No. 3, March 1860)
Various
England -- Periodicals; English literature -- Periodicals; Short stories, English -- Periodicals
This is very marvellous: so marvellous that a mind, trained in the
cultivated caution of science, will demand the evidence on which it
is based. Two months ago I should have dismissed the doubt with the
assurance that the evidence was ample and rigorous, and the fact
indisputable. For not only had the fact been confirmed by the united
experience of several investigators: it had stood the test of very severe
experiment. Thus in 1842, M. Doyère published experiments which seemed to
place it beyond scepticism. Under the air-pump he set some moss, together
with vessels containing sulphuric acid, which would absorb every trace of
moisture. After leaving the moss thus for a week, he removed it into an
oven, the temperature of which was raised to 300° Fahrenheit. Yet even
this treatment did not prevent the animals from resuscitating when water
was added.
In presence of testimony like this, doubt will seem next to impossible.
Nevertheless, my own experiments leave me no choice but to doubt. Not
having witnessed M. Doyère’s experiment, I am not prepared to say wherein
its fallacy lies; but that there _is_ a fallacy, seems to me capable of
decisive proof. In M. Pouchet’s recent work[11] I first read a distinct
denial of the pretended resuscitation of the Rotifers; this denial was
the more startling to me, because I had myself often witnessed the
reawakening of these dried animals. Nevertheless, whenever a doubt is
fairly started, we have not done justice to it until we have brought it
to the test of experiment; accordingly I tested this, and quickly came
upon what seems to me the source of the general misconception. Day after
day experiments were repeated, varied, and controlled, and with results
so unvarying that hesitation vanished; and as some of these experiments
are of extreme simplicity, you may verify what I say with little trouble.
Squeeze a drop from the moss, taking care that there is scarcely
any dirt in it; and, having ascertained that it contains Rotifers,
or Tardigrades,[12] alive and moving, place the glass-slide under a
bell-glass, to shield it from currents of air, and there allow the water
to evaporate slowly, but completely, by means of chloride of calcium, or
sulphuric acid, placed under the bell-glass; or, what is still simpler,
place a slide with the live animals on the mantelpiece when a fire is
burning in the grate. If on the day following you examine this perfectly
dry glass, you will see the contracted bodies of the Rotifers, presenting
the aspect of yellowish oval bodies; but attempt to resuscitate them by
the addition of a little fresh water, and you will find that they do not
revive, as they revived when dried in the moss: they sometimes swell a
little, and elongate themselves, and you imagine this is a commencement
of resuscitation; but continue watching for two or three days, and you
will find it goes no further. Never do these oval bodies become active
crawling Rotifers; never do they expand their wheels, and set the
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account