The County: The "Dark Continent" of American PoliticsGilbertson, Henry S.
History
The County: The "Dark Continent" of American Politics
Gilbertson, Henry S.
County government -- United States
In no branch of humanitarian service is segregation, classification,
even to the point of individual treatment, more essential than in the
care of the insane. New Jersey puts no inconsiderable number of her
mentally afflicted on a par with offenders against the criminal law
for, according to the Commission on the Care of the Mental Defectives
for the year 1913, fifteen counties had confined insane persons in
penal institutions, in some cases for periods of from 85 to 223 days.
The State Charity Commission in Illinois recently reported that in
spite of a provision of the statutes forbidding such practices, only
eleven of the 102 counties did not so offend. Louisiana is reported to
have many lunatics in its parish jails.
In but few states are there no insane in the county almshouses, for
at least temporary confinement, and particularly is this true in the
South and Middle West. In such institutions a condition sometimes
prevails that staggers imagination. For the state of Pennsylvania, Dr.
C. Floyd Haviland has summed up the situation in these words:
“As a result of the existing system, in these institutions, custodial
care is generally substituted for active remedial treatment directed
to the improvement or the recovery of the insane as such. As a
rule, medical treatment for physical ills is satisfactory, although
such is not invariably the case. With but few exceptions, the
county institutions have no special medical facilities, nor can
it be expected that such facilities can be provided under present
conditions, for, with the comparatively small number of patients
treated in the respective institutions, such provisions would require
a prohibitive _per capita_ expense; but as a result of such
lack of facilities, mechanical means of restraint and confinement
are substituted for proper personal treatment and attention. With
but a limited number of attendants, enclosed exercise yards and
personal restraint and seclusion must inevitably result. Under
existing conditions, one cannot blame the caretakers of the insane for
resorting to such means, for while restraint and seclusion can and
should be abolished, they cannot be successfully abolished without
the substitution of other means of dealing with the disturbed insane,
such as hydrotherapy, occupational training, and close personal
supervision. In this connection it is agreeable to note that little
evidence was obtained of actual physical abuse, but that gross neglect
exists is indisputable.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account