The Criticism of the Fourth Gospel: Eight Lectures on the Morse Foundation, Delivered in the Union Seminary, New York in October and November 1904Sanday, W. (William)
Religion
The Criticism of the Fourth Gospel: Eight Lectures on the Morse Foundation, Delivered in the Union Seminary, New York in October and November 1904
Sanday, W. (William)
Bible. John -- Criticism, interpretation, etc.
It is the equilibrium of these two propositions that is most
characteristic. I fully believe that motives of the same kind are
present among the Germans as well as ourselves. I could easily name a
number of German professors who, I feel sure, are as anxious to keep
their faith as we are. At the head of the list I should put Harnack
himself, whose views have been so much discussed in this country. There
is, however, a greater diversity of attitude among the professorial body
as a whole. And so far as they were agreed—I am speaking especially of
the widespread liberal branch—they would, I think, all invert the order
of the two propositions: they would give precedence to the desire to get
at realities; and they would identify this getting at realities with the
use of scientific method. The reason is that in Germany, more than
elsewhere, the prevalent standards of judgement are essentially
academic. The Universities give the lead and set the tone for the whole
nation; and the Universities have now been accustomed for many
generations to an atmosphere of free thought.
Now it is far from my intention to undervalue, either the use of
scientific method in general, or German science in particular. I have
the highest opinion of both. By far the greater part of the advance that
has been made in Theology—and I believe that a great advance has been
made in our own country as well as elsewhere—I would again appeal to
Hastings’ _Dictionary_ as representing a sort of average—has been due to
the stricter application of science; and a great part of this has been
German science. Honour must be given where honour is due. We must not
hold back the full recognition that at the present time Germany holds
the first place in Science, and that its output of scientific work is
perhaps as great as that of all the rest of the world besides. I am not
sure whether this is an exaggeration, but I hardly think it is.
But in all the more tentative forms of science, such as philosophy,
history, and theology, there is, or at least has been so far, a double
element, one that is stable and permanent, and another that is more or
less local and ephemeral.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account