These two questions, though in themselves of minor importance, gave
rise to a controversy of many years’ duration. Eventually the Roman
practice was adopted by the whole Celtic Church, but not without a
struggle, some localities clinging tenaciously to the traditional usage
long after the general acceptance of the Continental practice. The
Southern Irish were the first to conform. Having received an admonition
from Pope Honorius they convened a Synod about 630 A.D. and as a result
of their deliberations decided to adopt the Roman usage. The North
of Ireland held out much longer, being influenced by Iona and its
dependent monasteries in Ireland.[129] The dates at which the different
parts of the Celtic Church conformed with the Roman practice in regard
to the celebration of Easter are given below.[130] Possibly the coronal
form of tonsure was adopted at the same time.
YEAR.—DISTRICT AFFECTED BY THE CHANGE:[130]
630 A.D. South of Ireland.
664 Northumbria converted by Irish missionaries
from Iona.
692 North of Ireland.
705 East Devon and Somerset, the Celts
under Wessex.
710 The Picts of Scotland.
716–718 Iona.
721 Strathclyde, the South-west of Scotland.
768 North Wales.
777 South Wales.
909 Parts of Cornwall.
EFFECT OF THE EASTER CONTROVERSY ON EDUCATION:
The Irish monks who visited the Continent, as well as the adherents
of the Roman usage in Britain, advocated and even urged the necessity
of conforming to the Continental practices, but their compatriots
did not yield without a struggle. As we have shown, certain parts of
Britain in which the Celtic Church held sway were even more reluctant
to give up the traditional usages. So far as the general interests
of education are concerned this controversy had a somewhat harmful
effect. It diverted the attention of scholars from matters of greater
moment and created a certain prejudice against those Irish teachers
who were not prepared to give up the cherished customs of the founders
of their monasteries. For example, after the Synod of Whitby in 664
A.D. when Celtic usage was abolished, St. Colman and a number of
Anglo-Saxon followers retired from Lindisfarne and founded a monastery
on Inisbofinn, an island off the west coast of Ireland. It must not,
however, be assumed that the Irish influence in England ceased with
the departure of St. Colman and his followers. At the Synod of Whitby
some of the most vigorous advocates of the Roman usage were Irishmen,
while amongst the Anglo-Saxons there were many champions of the Celtic
usage.[131] For at least thirty years after the Synod of Whitby the
Irish influence was felt. A native ministry having been trained the
Irish monks had accomplished their work.[132] In one respect the Easter
controversy had a good effect on learning. It led to a careful study
of the computation and astronomy and created the necessity of becoming
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account