_Objections._--The following objections are raised by those who are
adverse to the institution of such marriage prohibitions as these:
(_a_) They limit personal freedom, and even in some cases actually
abolish it. (_b_) By means of marriage-prohibitions, it is possible
to limit the number of legitimate children born, but not the number
of children as a whole, since persons to whom legal marriage is
forbidden will in that case procreate illegitimate children. But
it is far from being desirable that this should happen. All the
defects previously enumerated would be present in such children,
and their birth would be unconditionally harmful to society. It is
statistically proved that marriage-prohibitions lead to an increase
in the number of illegitimate births. In Bavaria, for example, down
to the year 1868, the local authorities imposed an unconditional
veto upon the marriage of persons supported solely by wage-earning;
against this prohibition there was no appeal whatever. In the year
1868 was passed the law relating to marriage and domicile, by which
most of the former marriage-prohibitions were repealed. The sequel
of this was that, whereas from 1854 to 1868 illegitimate births
constituted 22 per cent. of all births, in the seven years following
1868 the percentage of illegitimate births fell to 12·6 per cent.
(_c_) It is better, say the objectors, that a man suffering from
venereal disease should marry, for in that case he makes only
one woman unhappy and procreates a few children only. But if he
is forbidden to marry, he has intercourse with numerous women,
especially with prostitutes, he infects many women, and procreates
more children. (_d_) Marriage-prohibitions do not prevent unhappy
marriages only, but also those which would be likely to prove happy.
Many couples enter into marriage for other reasons than desire
for sexual intercourse. There are also many sick persons upon
whom marriage exercises a curative influence--curing, or at least
alleviating, the disease from which they suffer. For example, many
alcoholics become abstemious or temperate as a result of marriage;
many weakly and delicate girls become strong and healthy women when
they marry. Many marriages are happy although husband and wife do not
practise sexual intercourse; and it is by no means uncommon for a
woman to marry a sick man simply because she pities him, and wishes
to act as his sick-nurse. (_e_) Marriage-prohibitions accentuate
class contrasts. (_f_) Diseased persons commonly have no offspring.
(_g_) Diseased persons to whom, after consideration of their case,
marriage is permitted, have the responsibility taken out of their
hands, and consequently tend to lose all sense of responsibility.
(_h_) Marriage-prohibitions interfere with natural selection,
inasmuch as they render impossible the acquirement of immunity to
disease and the process of regeneration. (_i_) It would be a logical
counterpart to marriage-prohibitions to compel healthy persons to
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account