The glory of the PharaohsWeigall, Arthur E. P. Brome (Arthur Edward Pearse Brome)
History
The glory of the Pharaohs
Weigall, Arthur E. P. Brome (Arthur Edward Pearse Brome)
Egypt -- Antiquities
The main argument in favour of the excavation of tombs by archæologists
is easily stated. The careful opening of an ancient Egyptian sepulchre
saves for science information and antiquities which otherwise would
inevitably be scattered to the four winds of heaven by native
plunderers. In spite of the strenuous efforts of the Department of
Antiquities, a considerable amount of robbery takes place in the ancient
cemeteries. Tombs are rifled, coffins are broken open, mummies torn to
pieces in the search for gold, heavy objects smashed into portable
fragments, and valuable papyri ripped into several parts to be
apportioned among the thieves. It will not be easy for the reader to
picture in his mind the disorder of a plundered tomb. There lies the
overturned sarcophagus, there sprawls the dead body with the head rent
from the shoulders, there are the shattered remains of priceless vases
believed by the robbers to have been of no great value. It is as though
the place had been visited at full moon by demented monkeys.
Compare this with scientific excavation. The archæologist records by
means of photographs, drawings, plans, and copious notes, everything
that there is to be recorded in the tomb. Before he raises the lid of
the shell in which the dead man lies he has obtained pictures of the
intact coffin at every angle; before he unrolls the bandages from the
mummy he has photographed it again and again. There is a rough decency
in his dealings with the dead, and a care in handling the contents of
the graves which would have been gratifying to their original owner.
Every object is taken from the sepulchre in an orderly manner, and the
body itself is either buried once more or is sent to the workroom of the
archæologist or anthropologist. A tomb which might be thoroughly
plundered in half an hour occupies the earnest attention of an
archæologist for several days; and the mummy which would have been
rapidly torn to pieces in the search for jewels is laboured over for
many an hour by men of science.
Which, then, is the better course: to leave the tombs to be rifled by
ignorant thieves, or to clear them of their contents in an orderly
manner? I do not see how there can be any doubt as to the answer.
But let us assume for the sake of argument that there is no illegal
robbery to be feared, and that the question is simply as to whether
these ancient tombs should be excavated or left undisturbed. What can be
said in favour of the molesting of the dead? What can be brought forward
to justify this tampering with oblivion?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account