The Historical Jesus: A Survey of PositionsRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Historical Jesus: A Survey of Positions
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ -- Historicity; Jesus Christ -- Rationalistic interpretations
His body was symmetrical, but his head was long out of all
proportion; for which reason in nearly all his statues he is
represented wearing a helmet; as the sculptors did not wish,
I suppose, to reproach him with this blemish.... Most writers
tell us that his tutor in music was Damon, whose name they say
should be pronounced with the first syllable short. Aristotle,
however, says that he studied under Pythocleides. This Damon,
it seems, was a sophist of the highest order....
The "biographer" who so satisfies Mr. Sinclair's sense of actuality has
not one word of this kind to say of the youth, upbringing, birthplace,
or appearance of the Teacher, who for him was either God or Supreme
Man. Seeking for the alleged "freedom and variety of life" in the
narrative, we go on to read:--
And they go into Capernaum; and straightway on the sabbath day he
entered into the synagogue and taught. And they were astonished
at his teaching: for he taught them as having authority, and not
as the scribes. And straightway there was in their synagogue a
man with an unclean spirit--
and straightway we are back in the miraculous. Mr. Joseph McCabe, who
in his excellent book on the Sources of the Morality of the Gospels
avows that he holds by the belief in a historical Jesus, though unable
to assign to him with confidence any one utterance in the record,
fatally anticipates Mr. Sinclair by remarking that "If the inquirer
will try the simple and interesting experiment of eliminating from the
Gospel of Mark all the episodes which essentially involve miracle,
he will find the remainder of the narrative amazingly paltry." To
which verdict does the independent reader begin to incline? Thus the
"episodes" continue, after three paragraphs of the miraculous:--
And in the morning, a great while before day, he rose up and went
out, and departed into a desert place, and there prayed. And Simon
and they that were with him followed after him; and they found him,
and say unto him, All are seeking thee. And he saith unto them, Let
us go elsewhere into the next towns, that I may preach there also;
for to this end came I forth. And he went into their synagogues
throughout all Galilee, preaching and casting out devils.
It would seem sufficient to say that Mr. Sinclair, with his "freedom
and variety of life," is incapable of critical reflection upon what he
reads. In the opening chapter we have not a single touch of actuality;
the three meaningless and valueless touches of detail ("a great
while before day" is the third) serve only to reveal the absolute
deficit of biographical knowledge. We have reiterated statements that
there was teaching, and not a syllable of what was taught. The only
utterances recorded in the chapter are parts of the miracle-episodes,
which we are supposed to ignore. Let us then consider the critic's
further asseveration:--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account