The historical novel : $b An essayButterfield, Herbert
History
The historical novel : $b An essay
Butterfield, Herbert
Historical fiction -- History and criticism
With these three fatalities that envelop mankind is mingled the
inward fatality--the highest fatality--the human heart.
This quotation alone is sufficient to show that the conception of the
Epic of Man rests, not upon the idea that the past is a new world for
the novelist to range in, but on a fact that is equally true from its
own point of view--the fact of the one-ness of experience and the unity
of the past with the present. The historical novel that is a universal
epic, therefore comes to men as an interpretation of Man’s experience
in the world. It is cosmic in conception. Also it is the work of a man
who is not merely novelist, but poet; for though experience is all one
piece, it comes to us in fragments and we only know it in parts, and
the man who wishes to understand it and to map out its meaning, must
in looking at past and present find a one-ness that is not apparent in
that mass of details and people and events that confront him; he must
divine a synthesis. This seems to be the conscious aim of Hugo, and
there is a tremendous power in his achievement that is not to be found
in the interpretation of large history that Merejkowski seeks to give
in his trilogy. In such works as these history as well as the novel is
carried beyond itself, and raised to a higher power.
The national epic is not so broad in its sweep, not so consciously an
interpretation of universal experience as what might be called the Epic
of Man. Here again it is not an individual that is the hero of the
story, but something that might almost be personified, a force working
in the lives of men; only, in this case, the stage of the drama is the
Nation at some tremendous moment in its history. The quiver through
a whole people of some breath of national feeling is described like
the stir of the wind upon a pool; the throb of a whole nation in some
intense crisis is caught into story. And as this surge of feeling in a
people becomes most apparent at the point at which it meets resistance,
no theme is better for this kind of novel than that which describes in
a people the bitter sense of national liberty thwarted, and of national
aspirations refused, the growing consciousness of repression and an
increasing desire to resist the oppressor. Where these exist love
of liberty comes as a yearning and an aspiration and a vision; fine
impulses become conscious because they strike against an obstacle; and
they become aggressive since they feel themselves thwarted. Nothing
makes a more powerful motive for a novel.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account