The historical novel : $b An essayButterfield, Herbert
History
The historical novel : $b An essay
Butterfield, Herbert
Historical fiction -- History and criticism
This epic of national liberty is often itself inspired by the national
aspirations it describes. Perhaps it would be too much to identify
it with the historical novelists of Eastern Europe, especially since
Hugo’s _Ninety-Three_, the hero of which has been described as being
the Revolution, is admitted to be one of the best examples of it; but
it seems fairly true to identify it chiefly with those countries in
which the sense of national aspirations being thwarted has recently
existed and has been an impulse to art and literature, and a good many
of the historical novels of Eastern European writers are distinguished
by the throb of national feeling that strikes through them. And this
kind of novel is specially calculated to produce the precise feeling
that it describes, to stir readers to the aspirations which are its
theme, and to be a force for liberty itself. Such a result is even
aimed at by writers, so that the novel becomes in danger of developing
into a novel with a purpose.
Victor Hugo’s _Ninety-Three_ is a striking example of the epic of
national freedom; and it illustrates much of the mind of its author
and much of the character of this type of novel. It has been said
that its hero is not a particular personage in the story, but rather
the Revolution itself. Hugo had the powerful grasp of the character
of large and complex masses of detail, the genius for synthesis, the
eagle-like sweep of an imagination that can comprehend a multitude of
things and combine them in one principle--the very things that were
needed to make a gigantic movement of the masses the theme of an epic.
In his descriptions of the Vendée there is a chapter on “the spirit of
the place” which shows his way of thinking; he demonstrates in fine
flights of comprehensive statement that “the configuration of the soil
decides many of man’s actions and the earth is more his accomplice than
people believe...,” and he describes the difference that exists between
the mountain insurgent like the Swiss, and the forest insurgent like
the Vendean: “The one almost always fights for an ideal, the other
for a prejudice. The one soars, the other crawls. The one combats for
humanity, the other for solitude. The one desires liberty, the other
wishes isolation. The one defends the commune, the other the parish....
The one has to deal with precipices, the other with quagmires....” The
voice of Hugo is in all this, and whether it is true or false it shows
a mind that jumps to synthesis. There is much more of the same kind
of generalising in this book, _Ninety-Three_, and often Hugo seems to
be preaching when he turns aside to throw out some incidental flashes
of it. He sees not only the trees but the contour of the land, the
character of the forest; he grasps not merely maddening events and a
confusion of men bustling with action, but divines the whole curve of
the mass-movement. He can speak of “the immense profile of the French
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account