The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 3, November, 1909Various
History
The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 3, November, 1909
Various
History -- Study and teaching -- Periodicals; Social sciences -- Study and teaching -- Periodicals
Of course, this is nothing more than the problem of selection which
confronts historians and teachers at many points, but rather more
persistently at some points than others. There is no patent solution
for the problem, but I believe it helps immensely to be thoroughly
alive to it, and to keep two principles steadily in mind when we
find the difficulty particularly acute--(1) that strong meat is not
for babes, and that the finer points of a discussion such as that
which concerns the growth of the lower branch of parliament should
be reserved for university work; (2) that though truth may be better
subserved by bringing out essentials clearly, even with over-emphasis,
yet it is possible to suggest qualifications which will leave loopholes
for further modification. For instance, the parliaments of 1265 and
1295 may be emphasized as the first and second steps in the beginning
of the House of Commons, yet it may be explained that as early as
John’s reign knights of the shire were occasionally summoned to
parliament.
I have dwelt at some length on this subject because, self-evident as it
may seem, it is full of pitfalls which only the utmost vigilance will
avoid.
A Plea for Life and Color.
Fortunately there is plenty of stirring action to offset the tedium
(to boys and girls) of laws and parliaments. Bannockburn, Crecy,
Poitiers, Agincourt--what an array of names to conjure with! Let us
not be parsimonious, fellow teachers, when we reach these vantage
grounds of glory! Let us not be ultra-orthodox in our scientific view
of history. In the reaction, the very proper reaction from the view
of history which made it a mere record of wars and battles there is
danger of making it a valley of dry bones. After all, it is the record
of life, and the events which have stirred the imagination and aroused
the patriotism of millions are not to be too lightly set aside. Let the
young imagination “drink delight of battle with its peers”; let it see
what was really noble as well as what was base in chivalry. Surely it
is worth while that it should catch the life and color of those middle
ages--so different, yet after all so human. Froissart has given us this
in a form now easily accessible, or failing a complete edition of his
“Chronicles,” Cheyney’s “Readings” furnish a taste (pp. 233-249), but
hardly enough, for only Crecy is here described. Green, as usual, is
vivid in his battle accounts--Bannockburn, pp. 213 and 214; Crecy,
Calais, and Poitiers, pp. 225-230; and Agincourt, pp. 267-268. Henry
V’s speech in Shakespeare’s play of “Henry V” is too splendid in its
rhetoric to be overlooked. Sometimes a laggard in the class loves to
declaim, and may be stirred to some interest by such a speech. Here is
the chance to make him useful.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account