The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 5, January 1910Various
History
The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 5, January 1910
Various
History -- Study and teaching -- Periodicals; Social sciences -- Study and teaching -- Periodicals
Mr. Ashley has added another excellent text on American history to the
numerous recent ones for secondary schools. The course of events is
carried down to 1907. “The subjects have been grouped under topical
heads. The author has hoped to indicate by this means the relation of
each historical change to the movement of the times and the relation
of this smaller movement to the larger phases of our development which
are given in the chapters” (preface). The attention given to wars is
agreeably less than in texts of some years ago,--only 100 pages out of
550. Industrial and social development, and economic phases are given
100 pages. These chapters are after the various epochal periods; they
are complete and attractive. Over 100 pages are given to the period
since the Civil War. All these proportions are in agreement with
the general trend in historical instruction to-day. The relation of
governmental institutions to historical development is especially clear.
The opening chapter is on geographic influences of America and the
early European background. Such sections in the book as follows are
illustrative of the clearness of topics usually difficult for high
school pupils:--40, “English Puritans”; 87, “English Colonists and
Their Governors,” where the temperament of governor is considered an
important factor; 265, distinction between Jeffersonian and Jacksonian
democracy; 330, “Fundamental causes of Secession”; 331, “Slavery and
state sovereignty vs. nationality”; 337-345, “Conditions affecting
Union Success.” It is a pleasure to note the comparative brief
description of such complicated military or naval movements as the
naval episodes of the War of 1812, the Shenandoah Valley campaign of
the Civil War (1864), the Vicksburg campaign, &c. The author is quite
fair in that period in which every American historian is most open to
the charge of being prejudiced,--the Civil War. He shows an impartial
attitude; he gives credit to both sides. The account is written in true
historical perspective without discrediting the value of the final
result. The bearing of lines of communication upon the course of wars
are indicated. Many will appreciate the omission of the names of the
assassins of the martyred President, probably the first school text to
do this.
There are a few defects: It is not evident from the account of the
Battle of Bunker Hill why it was called such, though fought on Breed’s
Hill. Certainly J. Q. Adams’ name should be given in connection
with the “gag resolution” of 1835. The sections of the copy of the
national constitution should be subdivided into clauses for convenient
reference. All of these points, however, are of minor importance and
hardly detract from the general high scholarship of the text.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account