The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 5, January 1910Various
History
The History Teacher's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 5, January 1910
Various
History -- Study and teaching -- Periodicals; Social sciences -- Study and teaching -- Periodicals
It is a comparatively easy matter to dispose of the remaining events
in this drama in which Luther, the Emperor and the Pope are the
main actors; but in what connection, and in how much detail, shall
the teacher present the beginnings of the reform movement in other
countries, the counter movement in the Catholic Church, and the
struggles which arose over questions of religion in every land where
Protestantism secured a foothold? The fact that sooner or later the
struggle between Catholics and Protestants resolved itself into a civil
war of considerable proportions makes it possible to utilize these
struggles as the principal unifying element in the treatment of the
entire period from 1521 to 1648. This plan differs from the ordinary
arrangement of material to be found in the text-book in that it places
less stress upon the beginnings of the reform movement outside of
Germany, subordinating these details to the wars as the central theme
and directing the attention of the student only to such events as
help to explain the character of these struggles. The teacher must,
however, bear in mind throughout that “the story of no European country
or group of countries in this troubled period admits of being told as
detached from the contemporary history of its neighbors, allies, or
adversaries.”[7] Beyond emphasizing the fact that the revolt spread
to other lands, it is a question whether the time is wisely spent in
treating in detail the Calvinistic movement emanating from Geneva,
or the beginnings of Presbyterianism in Scotland, or the overthrow
of Catholicism in England. The one central idea which the student
should grasp as a result of his study of the period--an idea which is
decidedly within the range of his comprehension and appreciation--is
that religion, which had long been a dominant factor in European
politics, now lost its power to sway the political destinies of thrones
and empires. In fact a new era had dawned in which the Church found
itself removed from politics and the world given over to interests of
quite a different character. This change may be illustrated further
along by the insignificant part taken by the representatives of the
Pope in the deliberations concerning the Treaties of Westphalia.
The growth of toleration should also be noted as an important
characteristic of this new period. Finally the student’s attention may
with profit be directed to the general tendency in these struggles
toward the subordination of the higher interests of religion to selfish
and dynastic interests. Time and again religion serves merely as a
cloak for the concealment of ambitions of the most secular character.
The ideals of true religion were perhaps never more perverted from
their true ends and made to serve the basest and lowest uses.
Outline of Plan of Presentation.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account