The journal of the American-Irish Historical Society, Vol. IX, 1910Various
History
The journal of the American-Irish Historical Society, Vol. IX, 1910
Various
American-Irish Historical Society -- Periodicals; Ethnology -- United States -- Periodicals; Irish Americans -- Periodicals
The Irishmen in North Carolina, largely Presbyterians in religion, were
unanimously patriotic as Americans from the beginning, and they did not
assimilate with the Scotchmen, who came direct from Scotland. Flora
MacDonald, whose story we all know, her five sons and her husband,
entered the British Army and continued throughout the Revolution; that
is, such of them as were not taken prisoners and expatriated to Nova
Scotia, where her descendants are today most vigorous supporters of
English rule. Her husband was early taken a prisoner of war and confined
at Halifax, Virginia, and in 1776 Flora went back to Scotland, where she
was afterwards rejoined by him.
To Worcester, Massachusetts, in the early Colonial days came three
hundred Irishmen from the Province of Ulster, probably many from my own
county of Donegal, to dwell among those ever hospitable and warm-hearted
gentlemen, the Puritans. Here was a fine combination—a “Scotch Irish”
Presbyterian meeting a Puritan, a Calvinistic Reunion! But how did they
act when these three hundred men and women from Ulster arrived in
Massachusetts? Perhaps some of you may think they were received with
great hospitality. Well, they were not. They were received, says a
“Scotch-Irish” historian, with marked aversion and bitter prejudice
against them as being Irish. A gentleman writing in favor of the so
called “Scotch Irish” in America says the New England colonists could
not differentiate these _Irish Protestants_, though they were different
in religion from the mass of Irishmen. Is not that a delicious
confession in the papers of the Scotch Irish Society? The Puritans could
not understand that they were anything but Irish; they recognized them
as such and did everything to make it unpleasant for them (and they were
artists in that work), and to get them out of the community as soon as
they could, short of inviting a physical controversy, for looking at
these stalwart Irishmen they made up their minds if it came to a fight,
they could, in the language of the Bowery, put up a “peach” of a one.
(Laughter and applause.)
The first man who died on the battlefield for American liberty, south of
Mason and Dixon’s line, was a great “Scotch-Irish” Anglo-Saxon named
John Grady; and when Grady died the captain of his army, Thomas Gove, a
family well known to any Donegal man, took off his sword and deposited
it with the body of Grady as a mark of respect and love for so brave and
patriotic a man.
Now our great American historians, from Bancroft and Motley and Parkman
down to Henry Cabot Lodge, have quietly ignored the Irish in America, or
have given all the credit for their achievements to this myth, the
“Scotch-Irishman.” It is a singular thing, when you read the things this
Society puts before you, the absolute facts of history, that no American
historian of Anglo-American ancestry has had the fairness and the
courage and the sense of justice to do for Ireland what so many of them
have done for other nationalities.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account