Well, then, says the teacher of current literature, there never can be
any great books, for you approve of nothing contemporary, and every
book, unfortunately, has to be written in its own time. Yes, in a sense,
anything you write, on however remote a subject, will be of your time and
will represent it; Walter Pater was expressing one phase of Victorian
England when he wrote _Marius the Epicurean_. But the artist hopes to
appeal to more than the present generation; even the most contemporary
of our contemporaries, who read no books of which the authors are not
living, cherish some ambition to have their own works read after they
themselves are gone. And since the fame of a book depends on its ability
to meet the interest of readers over a long period of time, the life
of our works will depend on two things—on our gift for selecting the
matter which is permanently interesting to men, and on the willingness
or unwillingness of any generation to be interested in the same things
as its predecessors. If readers are now brought up to neglect as a
matter of course any works of literature that once were loved, there
will be no fame for any one hereafter, and no masters of the art, but
only in each publishing season a nine days’ wonder. But if human nature
still asserts its primal interests, in spite of mistaken teaching, and
continues to like in the long run the same things that have been loved
in the past, then the writer will finally be reckoned great who answers,
not the mood of his hour, but the spirit of those constant demands. He
will get his inspiration from life as he knows it; he will express it
in an eternal form, as we say—at least in a form so durable that instead
of our understanding his work through the incident that inspired it, we
shall know of the incident through the work. Molière has so immortalized
one moment of his times in his _Précieuses Ridicules_; without the play,
would we know much of the temporary affectation? And to be quite frank,
has not something died in the play, along with what was contemporary in
it, so that we enjoy it now with an historical effort not needed to be
at home, let us say, with Falstaff? Tennyson really immortalized the
Charge of the Light Brigade, for the incident on so many grounds has
since proved regrettable that we should be glad to forget it, but for
the poem, and we begin to be sorry that the poem is anchored to so much
that was transitory. Our own civil war poet, Henry Howard Brownell, true
genius if we ever had one, wrote his verses on the very scene, after the
fights he had passed through as Farragut’s secretary on the flagship,
and the virulence of contemporary passion is in his work forever, an
embarrassing alloy. But of the danger of being contemporary, Dante is the
great illustration. It is not hard to see what an impact his great poem
must have made on his first hearers, it was so immediate in its reference
to persons, places, incidents, crimes and disasters which Florence, Rome
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account