The Monist, Vol. 1, 1890-1891 : $b A quarterly magazineVarious
Philosophy
The Monist, Vol. 1, 1890-1891 : $b A quarterly magazine
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
The difficulty described is especially felt in the following
considerations. In the complex _A B C_ ... which we have designated
as the material world, we find as part, not only our own body _K L M_
..., but also the bodies of other persons (or animals) _K' L' M'_ ...,
_K" L" M"_ ..., annexed to which, after the analogy of the complex α
β γ ..., we conceive similar α' β' γ' ..., α" β" γ". As long as we
deal with _K' L' M'_ ..., we find ourselves in a thoroughly familiar
province, at every point sensorially accessible to us. But when we
inquire after the sensations or feelings that belong to the body _K'
L' M'_ ..., we no longer find in the province of sense the elements we
seek: but we add them in thought. Not only is the domain into which we
now enter much less familiar to us, but also the transition to it is
relatively unsafe. We are possessed of a feeling as if we were about to
plunge into an abyss. They that always pursue this direction of thought
and this direction _only_, will never get completely rid of the feeling
of insecurity that is very productive as a source of apparent problems.
But we are not limited to this way of reasoning. Let us consider first
the reciprocal relation of the elements of the complex _A B C_ ...,
without regarding _K L M_ ... (our body). Every physical investigation
is of this kind. A white bullet falls upon a bell; a sound is heard.
The bullet turns yellow before a sodium lamp, red before a lithium
lamp. Here the elements (_A B C_ ...) appear to be connected only
_among each other_ and to be independent of our body (_K L M_ ...).
But if we take santonine the bullet turns yellow again. If we turn one
eye sidewise we see two bullets. If we close our eyes entirely we see
no bullet at all. If we sever our auditory nerve no sound is heard.
The elements _A B C_ ..., therefore, are not only connected among
each other, but also with _K L M_. To this extent and to this extent
_only_ do we call _A B C_ ... _sensations_, and regard _A B C_ ... as
belonging to the ego. In this way, accordingly, we do not meet with
the gap between bodies and sensations before described, between that
which is without and that which is within, between the material and the
spiritual world.[19] All elements _A B C_ ... _K L M_ ... constitute
but _one single_ coherent mass, which when any one element in it is
disturbed _all_ is put in motion; except that a disturbance has a more
extensive and profound action in _K L M_ ..., than in _A B C_. A magnet
in our neighborhood disturbs the particles of iron near it; a falling
boulder shakes the earth; but the severing of a nerve sets in motion
the _entire_ system of elements. Quite involuntarily does this relation
of things suggest the picture of a viscous mass, at certain places (as
in the ego) more firmly coherent than at others.
[19] Compare my _Grundlinien der Lehre von den
Bewegungsempfindungen_. Leipsic, Engelmann, 1875, p. 54.
* * * * *
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account