In the second place, the two-drive theory is not fundamental in its own
sense of the term “fundamental drive.” For, since sexual reproduction
is known to have been preceded by a-sexual, and since a-sexual
reproduction roots in cell-division as a phase of nutrition, the
conclusion, upon the assumed basis, should be that there is only one
basic drive, the nutritional!
In the third place, the theory confuses instead of clarifying human
conduct in the sphere of sex and reproduction. Desire for sex-relations
is not by any means the same as desire for offspring or for the
maintenance of our species. Our race had been on the scene a long time
before anybody suspected the causal relation between the sex function
and the birth of babies. Desire for children does not root in sex
appetite; it arises only after being with children. Desire for the
maintenance of our species arises, of course, only through reflection,
and its object is apprehended only through imagination. As a matter of
unadorned fact, does not the sex-impulsion in human beings struggle to
free itself from all necessary association with reproduction?
A fourth consideration concerns the other supposedly basic and
inclusive drive, the nutritional. If we take the impulse to eat in its
primary and simple sense, then we must see that a plentiful supply of
food at any moment produces quiescence of food-getting activities;
a full belly is, so to say, the _summum bonum_ of this branch of
motivation. But the theory goes on to classify with food-getting a
whole lot of other activities of getting, storing, guarding, and
competing--almost the whole economic system, indeed. In subsequent
chapters (15 and 16) we shall see how complicated, in fact, is the
motivation of our system of production and distribution. At the present
moment it is sufficient to point out how strained is the theory that
all our individualistic getting is at bottom food-getting, and that all
individualistic getting is directed towards the prolongation of the
individual’s existence.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account