The New Irish Constitution: An Exposition and Some Arguments
History
The New Irish Constitution: An Exposition and Some Arguments
Home rule -- Ireland; Ireland -- Politics and government
I may here cite one or two examples of modern Constitutions which have
laid down principles designed to secure religious equality.(88) Naturally
Switzerland, with its population nearly equally divided into Catholics and
Protestants, has been obliged to deal with this question, and so far as I
am aware, it has done so with success. The principles of religious
equality are embodied in the amended Constitution of 1874. I quote the
chief provisions, because they are on the whole the most complete set of
existing safeguards which I have found.
“_Article_ 49.—La liberté de conscience et de croyance est
inviolable. Nul ne peut être constraint de faire partie d’une
association religieuse, de suivre un enseignement religieux,
d’accomplir un acte religieux, ni encourir des peines, de quelque
nature quelles soient, pour cause d’opinion religieuse.
“L’exercice des droits civils ou politiques ne peut être restreint
par des prescriptions ou des conditions de nature ecclésiastique
ou religieuse, quelles qu’elles soient.
“Nul ne peut, pour cause d’opinion religieuse, s’affranchir de
l’accomplissement d’un devoir civique.
“Nul n’est tenu de payer des impôts dont le produit est
spécialement affecté aux frais proprement dits du culte d’un
communauté religieuse à laquelle il n’appartient pas. L’exécution
ultérieure de ce principe reste réservée à la legislation
fédérale.
“_Article_ 50.—Le libre exercice des cultes est garanti dans les
limites compatibles avec l’ordre public et les bonnes mœurs.
“_Article_ 54.—Le droit de mariage est placé sous la protection de
la conféderation.
“Aucun empêchement au mariage ne peut être fondé sur des motifs
confessionels.”
While declaring the principle of liberty of conscience, the Swiss Federal
Constitution permits the cantons to give a privileged position to certain
religious denominations; they may give them subsidies; they may invest
them with certain prerogatives denied to other bodies less favoured. For
example, in Fribourg, the Catholic and the Protestants are put on a
footing of equality. Owing to the powers possessed by the separate cantons
religious equality is not so complete as at first sight might seem. No
serious difficulty appears to have been experienced in giving effect to
the above provisions(89) which are not so complete as those found in the
Home Rule Bill.
III. SAFEGUARDS IN COLONIES
I come to legislation which may seem of a kind more helpful and
instructive than that of Continental countries. In the British Colonies
there is no connection between the State and Church. The sole important
exception is in Canada, where “the church can compel by law the payment of
dues by Roman Catholics, and thus obtains great privilege from, while
independent of, the State.”(90)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account