The New Irish Constitution: An Exposition and Some Arguments
History
The New Irish Constitution: An Exposition and Some Arguments
Home rule -- Ireland; Ireland -- Politics and government
I shall not attempt to measure the relative strength of these influences,
but I should be inclined to rate highest the ultimate effect of democracy,
and of a Parliament in which must be a Protestant minority powerful by
their talents, their wealth and their energy. Democracy has everywhere its
own problems, as engrossing for it as any in which the Church is
interested. It will solve them in its own way, which may not be always the
Church’s. “Nothing,” says Mr. Bryce with reference to America, “excites
more general disapproval than any attempt by an ecclesiastical
organisation to interfere in politics.” Under democratic institutions
there may be the same results in Ireland. The remodelling of primary
education will probably be one of the first struggles in which an Irish
Parliament will be engaged. The fight will be in the open, which is a
clear gain. The Church may for a time succeed in retaining its present
hold over the schools. It is quite as likely that it will lose ground, and
that the first Irish Minister of Education will be the first to incur
ecclesiastical censure. There is much evidence of the growth of a
widespread toleration extending it may be hoped, to the northeast corner
of Ulster:
“Since the Local Government Act of 1898,” writes Mr. Annan Bryce,
“it has not been found that the priest interferes unless in the
rare cases where there is a question of personal morality, and
then not always with success.”
The opinions of three Lord-Lieutenants upon this point cannot be ignored.
Lord Aberdeen:
“After years of continuous residence in Ireland, watching affairs
and meeting people of every class and creed, I am profoundly
impressed with the baselessness of alarm about the consequences of
Home Rule.
“On Home Rule for Ireland, I repeat and emphasise the opinion of
my former telegrams, especially regarding apprehension of
religious intolerance.”
The late Lord Spencer:
“I have had some experience of Ireland, and yet I do not know any
specific instance where there has been the exercise of religious
intolerance on the part of the Roman Catholics against their
Protestant countrymen.”
The Marquis of Crewe:
“In 1886 and 1893 the animosity between classes, largely agrarian
in its origin, was far stronger than at present, and the line of
cleavage roughly followed that of religious difference. But even
in those days, as I well remember, it was evident that the
possibilities of intolerance in a self-governed Ireland were
deliberately and grossly exaggerated, with a party motive. Now,
when the various classes know each other better, and there is less
occasion for friction, the attempt to excite religious discord
will utterly fail, as I firmly believe.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account