Butler, Samuel, 1835-1902 -- Notebooks, sketchbooks, etc.
What I want to do now [1885] is to connect vibrations not only with
memory but with the physical constitution of that body in which the
memory resides, thus adopting Newland’s law (sometimes called
Mendelejeff’s law) that there is only one substance, and that the
characteristics of the vibrations going on within it at any given time
will determine whether it will appear to us as (say) hydrogen, or sodium,
or chicken doing this, or chicken doing the other. [This touched upon in
the concluding chapter of _Luck or Cunning_? 1887.]
I would make not only the mind, but the body of the organism to depend on
the characteristics of the vibrations going on within it. The same
vibrations which remind the chicken that it wants iron for its blood
actually turn the pre-existing matter in the egg into the required
material. According to this view the form and characteristics of the
elements are as much the living expositions of certain vibrations—are as
much our manner of perceiving that the vibrations going on in that part
of the one universal substance are such and such—as the colour yellow is
our perception that a substance is being struck by vibrations of light,
so many to the second, or as the action of a man walking about is our
mode of perceiving that such and such another combination of vibrations
is, for the present, going on in the substance which, in consequence, has
assumed the shape of the particular man.
It is somewhere in this neighbourhood that I look for the connection
between organic and inorganic.
The Universal Substance
i
We shall never get straight till we leave off trying to separate mind and
matter. Mind is not a thing or, if it be, we know nothing about it; it
is a function of matter. Matter is not a thing or, if it be, we know
nothing about it; it is a function of mind.
We should see an omnipotent, universal substance, sometimes in a
dynamical and sometimes in a statical condition and, in either condition,
always retaining a little of its opposite; and we should see this
substance as at once both material and mental, whether it be in the one
condition or in the other. The statical condition represents content,
the dynamical, discontent; and both content and discontent, each still
retaining a little of its opposite, must be carried down to the lowest
atom.
Action is the process whereby thought, which is mental, is materialised
and whereby substance, which is material, is mentalised. It is like the
present, which unites times past and future and which is the only time
worth thinking of and yet is the only time which has no existence.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account