“One must consider, my son, that men joined one to another in the
succession of the ages by a chain of which they see but a few links,
attach the notion of nobility to customs whose origin was lowly and
barbarous. Their ignorance feeds their vanity. They found their glories
on old, unhappy, far-off things, and the nobility of the profession of
arms is due entirely to that savagery of early times of which the Bible
and the poets have preserved the remembrance. And what, in fact, is
this military nobility flaunted with so much pride over us, if not the
debased legacy of those unfortunate hunters of the woods whom the poet
Lucretius has depicted in such a way that one does not know if they be
men or beasts? It is wonderful, Tournebroche, my son, that war and
the chase, of which the thought alone should overwhelm us with shame
and remorse when we recall the wretched needs of our nature and our
inveterate wickedness, serve on the contrary, as matter for vain-glory
to men, that Christian peoples should continue to honour the profession
of butcher and executioner, when it is of old standing in families,
and that finally one estimates among refined people the celebrity of
citizens by the quantity of murders and carnage that they bear so to
speak, in their veins.”
“Monsieur l’Abbé,” I said to my good master, “do you not think that the
profession of arms is looked upon as noble because of the danger one
runs therein and the courage that it is necessary to display?”
“Truly, my son,” answered my good master, “if the state of man is noble
in proportion to the danger that he runs I do not fear to state that
peasants and labourers are the noblest men in the kingdom for they risk
death every day by fatigue or hunger. The perils to which soldiers and
commanders expose themselves are less in number and in duration, they
last but a few hours in a lifetime, and consist in facing cannon-balls
and bullets which kill less surely than poverty. Men must needs be
light and frivolous, my son, to give more honour to a soldier’s doings
than to the work of a labourer and to place the destruction of war at a
higher price than the arts of peace.”
“Monsieur l’Abbé,” I asked again, “do you not consider that soldiers
are necessary to the safety of the state and that we should honour them
in recognition of their usefulness?”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account