The Origin and Development of Christian Dogma: An essay in the science of historyTuthill, Charles A. H.
Religion
The Origin and Development of Christian Dogma: An essay in the science of history
Tuthill, Charles A. H.
Christianity -- Origin
As he extended the area of his labours and began to come in contact
with the people of the towns, he would find himself in face of
serious opposition. Here he would meet, not simple rustics who cared
little about ritual and politics, but legalists and nationalists
prompt to condemn him as irreligious and unpatriotic. The credulity
of his country disciples would be challenged and his Messianic
claims subjected to a hostile scrutiny. The tendency to dwell on the
supernatural inseparable from such a character as his would be in
sharp contrast to the spirit of worldliness he would encounter. Some
Sadducees even would be likely to confront him, requiring proof of the
postulates of his teaching, and infecting others with their scepticism.
Then would begin a time of struggle and irritation. All who looked
for the national Messiah would be enemies of Christ. They would be
eager upholders of the formal and exclusive elements of Judaism, and
his disregard of these would excite their bitter opposition. If he
neglected traditional ceremonies or associated with the outcasts of
formalism, he would be denounced as a breaker of the law, and the
friend of publicans and sinners. Gradually this opposition would
produce its effect. As the minor customs of the law were more and
more put before him as matters of sole importance, he would be forced
into hostility against them; as the outcries of the legalists grew
stronger, the whole system of legalism would become more discredited
with him. But, above all, he would lose his expectation of converting
Israel. When he realized by experience the strength of the obstacles
to his ideal, he would be compelled to reconsider his whole position as
Messiah.
The effect of this would be to drive him strongly towards
supernaturalism. From the beginning he must have been disposed to put
aside the ordinary conditions of life. The exaggerated and unworkable
morality of the gospels is probably an accurate representation of his
teaching. With his attention fixed on the spiritual glories of the
Messianic age, the worldly arrangements around him must have seemed
too transient to be worthy of attention. This feature of his character
would now enable him to meet the difficulty of his position. He would
turn from earth to heaven. Believing in the resurrection of the dead,
he would use it to justify his claim to be the Messiah. Rejected by the
greater part of his countrymen, no demonstration of his power on earth
could be pointed to, but he still could proclaim for himself the future
glory of a second coming in the clouds of heaven.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account