Archaeology; Civilization, Ancient; Despotism; Greece -- History -- To 146 B.C.; Wealth
Herodotus and Diodorus[465] had both visited Egypt and are among our
best authorities. At first sight indeed they do not seem quite in
agreement. But the story they tell is essentially the same. The
difference is one of emphasis. Herodotus seizes on a single incident and
makes much of the description of the Ionians and Carians as men of
bronze. The point was worth emphasizing; for from the military point of
view the first appearance of the heavy-armed hoplite in Egyptian history
marked an epoch[466]. Diodorus contradicts Herodotus only in stating
that it was not an accident that led Psammetichus to employ these
foreign hoplites[467]. The rest of his narrative only supplements
Herodotus, and the silence of Herodotus is no reason for thinking that
the later historian was not drawing on good and early sources[468]. Even
Herodotus could not incorporate in his history every scrap of knowledge
that he possessed, and for Egypt in the seventh century there may well
have been contemporary documents which were not consulted by Herodotus
but were by Diodorus. Diodorus’ account has in fact been accepted by a
considerable number of modern scholars[469]. [Sidenote: Cp. Strabo on
the Fort of the Milesians] They point out that it agrees with the
statement of Strabo about the Fort of the Milesians[470] that “in the
days of Psammetichus the Milesians sailed with 30 ships and put in at
the Bolbitine mouth, and disembarking built the foundation just
mentioned.”
There is one difficulty in this passage of Strabo. Psammetichus is
described in it as the contemporary of Cyaxares king of the Medes, who
reigned from 624 to 584 B.C., so that the Psammetichus referred to might
be Psammetichus II (594–589). But Psammetichus in Strabo appears
elsewhere always to mean the first and most important king of that name.
Cyaxares too both from his date and his nationality is an odd person for
a Greek writer to quote in order to indicate the date of an Egyptian
king[471]. Hirschfeld is therefore probably right in rejecting this
parenthesis as a learned but unintelligent gloss[472].
The Bolbitine mouth of the Nile is near the great lake and marshes of
Bourlos[473]. Psammetichus I, before he overcame his rivals in Lower
Egypt, is said by Herodotus[474] to have spent a period of exile in the
marshes, and the marshes are shown by the context to have lain near the
sea[475]. Thus quite apart from Diodorus, by simply comparing Herodotus
and Strabo, a case may be made for thinking that the arrival of the
bronze men from Ionia was not the accidental occurrence that Herodotus,
after his way, makes it out to have been, but that it had some close
connexion with the Milesians’ Fort.
[Sidenote: and Assurbanipal on help sent to Psammetichus by Gyges of
Lydia.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account